ABC alleges retaliation in US regulator’s early licence review


The US broadcast regulator acknowledges other enforcement tools but defends early renewal. ABC asks a judge to halt the review of eight stations’ licences.
ABC alleged in a 12 October court filing that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the US broadcast regulator, showed a retaliatory motive by requiring early licence renewal despite having less intrusive enforcement options. The FCC acknowledged those alternatives in a court-requested filing on 9 October but defended early renewal as the “best tool for the task before the agency”, Deadline reported on 12 October.
The dispute follows the FCC’s April order requiring eight ABC-owned television stations to apply years early to renew their broadcast licences. The agency said ABC had not adequately answered document requests in an investigation into Disney’s diversity, equity and inclusion practices. ABC, its parent Disney and its station group sued in August, alleging punishment for speech protected by the First Amendment, including news coverage and Jimmy Kimmel’s programming disfavoured by President Donald Trump. The order requires early renewal; it does not revoke the licences.
At the 6 October hearing, US District Judge Loren AliKhan asked the government to explain the employment-practices investigation and other ways to resolve the document dispute. She set a 9 October deadline for further written arguments. The FCC’s filing acknowledged that it could issue administrative subpoenas—formal demands for evidence—impose monetary penalties or hold hearings.
The government’s attorney said subpoenas and monetary penalties would require Justice Department enforcement, whereas the FCC had opened an early-renewal proceeding that included a public comment period. The government argued that the legal question was whether the FCC lawfully chose early renewal, not whether it could have selected another tool.
ABC’s 12 October reply drew the opposite conclusion. Its lawyers alleged that the FCC chose early renewal to exert “maximal coercive pressure” on a media company whose speech the administration sought to curb, while deliberately evading judicial review. ABC argued that the agency’s explanations for rejecting less intrusive options reinforced its allegation of retaliation.
At the 6 October hearing, ABC attorney Beth Wilkinson said regulatory threats were affecting editorial decisions, including midterm-election coverage. Deadline and the Guardian reported her arguments on 6 October.
Wilkinson said The View was forgoing political-candidate clips in its “Hot Topics” segment during the 2026 election cycle because of concern about FCC scrutiny under the equal-time rule. That rule requires broadcasters featuring qualified candidates to offer comparable time to their rivals. ABC maintains that The View has long qualified for a news-programming exemption. The FCC opened an investigation in February after the show featured Texas US Senate candidate James Talarico.
Wilkinson also said ABC carried Trump’s July speech on its streaming service, ABC News Live, but not its broadcast network, because it feared his anger if it did not carry the speech at all. Trump criticised ABC and NBC for not broadcasting it.
Wilkinson cited ABC’s decision to show Kimmel’s interview with Talarico on YouTube rather than television “because the FCC has no control over YouTube”. She presented the platform choice as another example of fear of regulatory retaliation affecting programming.
Assistant US Attorney Dimitar P. Georgiev, representing the FCC, disputed that connection. He said there was “no reason to believe” the early-renewal order had changed ABC’s editorial decisions and argued that its references to The View did not establish a link to licence renewal.
At the hearing, Georgiev described early renewal as a “tool” to speed up the investigation into potential violations of federal equal-opportunity rules governing employment. He said the process was “not about the licenses” and that the FCC could end the review early if ABC satisfied its document requests.
The employment investigation began in 2025, with document requests continuing since then. AliKhan asked why the FCC had only determined in the summer that Disney’s responses were inadequate and why all eight stations had to apply simultaneously. She also questioned the connection between the investigation, handled by the enforcement bureau, and the licence order, issued by the media bureau.
AliKhan also questioned the government about FCC Chairman Brendan Carr’s July comment that ABC’s decision not to broadcast Trump’s speech could factor into the licence investigation. She asked what made the document dispute different enough to require early renewal rather than another enforcement action. She ended the roughly two-hour hearing on 6 October without issuing an order, taking the matter under advisement.
Payments will begin with January 2021 usage. Publishers and administrators must pay or credit songwriters at least half of the amount attributable to their works.
4 min

The October 10-dated ranking places Kenny Chesney at No. 7, with nearly 30,000 album purchases contributing to his 35,000 equivalent album units.
2 min

The company targets the savings by the end of 2028. Ynon Kreiz says labor will account for less than half; the number of jobs and timing of notifications remain unspecified.
8 min