Michael Smith sentenced to 18 months for SI-song streaming fraud

The court also ordered $8.09 million in forfeiture. Both sides agreed on the loss after deductions, but disputed how much Smith personally pocketed.

The court also ordered $8.09 million in forfeiture. Both sides agreed on the loss after deductions, but disputed how much Smith personally pocketed.
Judge John G. Koeltl sentenced Michael Smith to 18 months in prison at an October 6, 2026 hearing in Manhattan federal court, Billboard reported that day. Music Business Worldwide reported on October 7 that the judge also ordered Smith to forfeit $8.09 million—the loss agreed by prosecutors and the defence, rather than his total royalty receipts.
Smith, a North Carolina man, pleaded guilty on March 19 to one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud. His scheme used bots—automated computer programs—to stream songs generated by artificial-intelligence (superintelligence (SI)) systems billions of times and collect music royalties. Royalties are payments to songwriters and other rights holders for the use of their music.
The prison term was shorter than prosecutors requested, but the court did not grant the defence’s request for no imprisonment. Both sides agreed on the federal sentencing guidelines range, which judges use as a starting point. The US Probation Office recommended a shorter term.
| Outcome or position | Prison term |
|---|---|
| Court’s sentence | 18 months |
| Prosecutors’ request | At least 46 months |
| Defence’s request | No imprisonment |
| US Probation Office’s recommendation | 24 months |
| Federal sentencing guidelines range | 46–57 months |
| Maximum sentence for the charge | 60 months, or five years |
Billboard described the case as the first criminal conviction for streaming fraud. In its October 6 report, the publication said Smith’s attorney had not immediately responded to a request for comment after sentencing.
Forfeiture requires Smith to give up the proceeds of the crime. The $8.09 million order matches the amount provided for in his plea agreement and requested by prosecutors before sentencing.
Music Business Worldwide reported on September 30 that the US Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York had submitted an 11-page sentencing letter to Koeltl. Dated September 28 and filed on September 29, it sought imprisonment and forfeiture of the agreed loss.
According to the government’s sentencing letter, as reported by Music Business Worldwide, Smith received more than $14 million from organisations that pay music royalties. The agreed loss was lower because the calculation deducted estimated royalties from legitimate streams of his music and money he paid back into royalty pools by purchasing the streaming accounts his bots used.
| Measure | Amount |
|---|---|
| Total receipts reported in the government’s sentencing letter | More than $14 million |
| Agreed loss after deductions, also ordered forfeited | $8,091,843.64 |
The defence did not dispute the loss figure. It disputed what that figure said about Smith’s personal gain: in an October 2 letter, his lawyers argued that the loss far exceeded the amount he actually pocketed. Prosecutors had argued that every penny of the loss was diverted to Smith.
The financial harm follows from how services such as Spotify distribute royalties. They do not pay a fixed rate for each play. Instead, rights holders share a pool tied to the service’s revenue, with each track’s share determined by its proportion of streams. Smith’s fake streams therefore reduced payments to other rights holders drawing from the same pools. In its court letter, The Mechanical Licensing Collective (The MLC) described streaming fraud as redirecting money from legitimate rights holders to fraudsters.
Smith was indicted in September 2024 on charges of wire fraud, wire fraud conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy. Prosecutors then alleged that he had taken more than $10 million. After the indictment, Spotify told Music Business Worldwide that its preventive measures had limited the royalties Smith generated on its platform to about $60,000.
Prosecutors said Smith spread artificial plays across hundreds of thousands of SI-generated songs to avoid detection. According to their account, the scheme ran from 2017 to 2024 and used thousands of fake accounts on services including Spotify, Apple Music, Amazon Music and YouTube Music.
| Catalog | Streams |
|---|---|
| Michael Smith | 80.9 million |
| Taylor Swift’s entire catalog | 9.3 million |
Smith’s lawyers sought probation rather than prison, arguing that losses were spread across millions of songwriters and artists and were tiny for each person. Prosecutors argued that spreading losses widely did not reduce Smith’s gain. They distinguished his case from securities fraud cases in which shareholders may lose substantial sums while the defendant gains relatively little, and said Smith prepared profit-and-loss statements showing how much he could earn from each bot.
Prosecutors also challenged Smith’s explanations for his conduct:
The defence’s October 2 letter offered a different account of the lawyer’s knowledge. It said disclosures prosecutors made in August 2025 included a witness who confirmed that the lawyer knew Smith was manipulating streams and had computers running bots in his office.
Prosecutors also cited a $900,000 civil settlement, announced in September 2020, involving Smith and two other defendants. The allegations concerned billing Medicare and Medicaid for medically unnecessary procedures at a North Carolina health care practice Smith helped manage. The Justice Department said there had been no determination of liability.
Prosecutors argued that the civil case should have warned Smith to be careful when obtaining money from others. Their letter described the streaming scheme as beginning “shortly after resolving” those allegations. Music Business Worldwide noted that the settlement was announced about three years after the scheme’s stated 2017 start.
Before sentencing, the Music Fights Fraud Alliance argued that Smith’s case, as the first US criminal prosecution for streaming fraud, would send the first real signal about its legal consequences.
A similar case had already reached a court outside the US. In February 2025, Denmark’s Western High Court increased a Danish man’s prison sentence from 18 to 24 months after his conviction for using bots to inflate streams on 689 tracks.
After his prison term, Smith is due to serve two years of supervised release, during which he will remain under court supervision.

At the 10 October ceremony in Ghent, Belgium, Pemberton and Russo won the film and television composer prizes, while “Golden” from “KPop Demon Hunters” took best original song.
4 min

Variety has presented two pieces from Desplat's music for Aaron Sorkin's film about Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen, including 'The Lament' featuring Renée Fleming. Desplat says his challenge was finding when music could join the actors' performances. The soundtrack is due Oct. 9.

The deal would move K-pop intellectual property and the revenue it earns onto Soneium through DayOneDream's WAVIST platform. The companies have not said which artists are involved, how big any offering will be or when the first assets will go on sale.
5 min