US jury orders Apple to pay $5.7bn over iPhone and Apple Watch vibration patents


A jury in California found that Apple infringed two patents held by the audio firm Taction Technology. The patents cover the haptic vibration technology used in iPhones and Apple Watches. Apple says it will appeal.
A US jury awarded Taction Technology $5.7 billion (£4.3 billion) in September 2026 after finding that Apple’s Taptic Engine infringed two of the audio firm’s vibration-technology patents. Taction has since asked for additional damages, interest and royalties through 24 September 2035, according to a 19 October report by 9to5Mac citing Reuters. The judge has not entered final judgment, and the additional payments have not been ordered.
The BBC reported the verdict on 28 September 2026. Jurors did not find that Apple’s infringement was deliberate, or “wilful”.
According to Taction’s filing, as reported by 9to5Mac citing Reuters, the jury award covered Apple’s sales only through March 2026. Taction seeks supplemental damages for another six months of iPhone and Apple Watch sales.
Taction also requests interest dating back to April 2021, proposing an annual rate of 7% under California law for the period before final judgment. It seeks additional interest from the date of final judgment until Apple pays.
For future sales, Taction asks for royalties—payments for using its patented technology—through 24 September 2035, when the patents are set to expire. It wants Apple to submit quarterly reports of US sales and pay royalties within 30 days of each quarter’s end.
The request extends to newer devices, including the iPhone 18 Pro, iPhone 18 Pro Max, Apple Watch Series 12 and Apple Watch Ultra 4. Taction alleges that these models use essentially the same technology as the products the jury found to infringe. That allegation about the newer devices is part of Taction’s request, not a further court ruling.

His five-year contract includes a $31.5 million signing stock award. He starts Oct. 5 to oversee daily operations and integration; the Warner Bros. Discovery merger is expected to close Oct. 6.
Haptics simulate touch through vibrations, such as the feedback a device gives when a message arrives or a button is pressed. Smartphones, watches and video game controllers use small motors that respond to electronic signals. Apple introduced its Taptic Engine with the Apple Watch in 2014, then improved the system and expanded haptics across its devices.
Taction, which makes headphones and gaming headsets, received the patents in 2020 and sued in 2021. It alleged that Apple’s improvements infringed those patents, improved the experience of using Apple devices and allowed Apple to profit from Taction’s inventions without a licence. A San Diego judge ruled in 2023 that Apple did not infringe the patents. A federal appeal led to the September 2026 jury trial at the US District Court for the Southern District of California.
The BBC described the dispute as one of several similar lawsuits Apple has defended in recent years. In November 2025, a judge ordered Apple to pay medical technology firm Masimo $634 million after a jury found infringement of a blood-oxygen reading patent. The Taction jury award is about nine times that amount.
Apple denied using Taction’s technology and said it would appeal. It called the verdict and damages unsupported by the facts, saying its Taptic Engine is fundamentally different and that Taction’s own testing during the trial confirmed that difference.
Apple has asked the court to overturn the verdict or order a new trial. It argues that Taction failed to provide evidence supporting the $5.7 billion award, leaving jurors to engage in “impermissible guesswork on a massive scale”. As of 19 October, the court still had to resolve Apple’s challenge and Taction’s payment requests, as well as enter final judgment.
6 min

The Indian celebrity talk show will return for a ninth and final season on JioHotstar from October 14. Johar says he wants to spend the next decade directing films.
3 min

The Armenian airline has turned a preliminary deal, announced during Emmanuel Macron's May visit, into an order for two larger aircraft with 239 seats each. Delivery dates and new routes have not been announced.
2 min