Lawmaker challenges Apple’s reasons for removing ICE-tracking apps and asks for a full list


Rep. Jamie Raskin says there is no evidence linking the apps to a deadly shooting at an ICE office in Dallas. His letter adds to a lawsuit asking whether US officials pushed Apple to remove them.
Apple removed ICEBlock and other apps that let people track US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers from its App Store. A member of Congress is now demanding that the company show its reasoning. In a letter sent Monday, Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) said Apple has no evidence that the apps created safety risks. CNN reported the letter.
Raskin asked Apple to "send a full list of the apps it removed following concerns from the Justice Department." He said the list would make it possible to "conduct an independent review of those removal decisions." He also wrote that Apple appears to be "working with the government to violate its customers' First Amendment rights to record and report on the activities of their own government." The First Amendment is the part of the US Constitution that protects free speech. Raskin had been pressing Apple for answers for months.
Apple answered Raskin in July in a letter signed by Timothy Powderly, its senior director of government affairs. Apple said it removed ICEBlock and other apps after a fatal shooting at an ICE office in Dallas. Two detainees died in that attack. The shooter, Joshua Jahn, fired indiscriminately into the building and then died of a self-inflicted gunshot. In notes, he wrote that he "hoped his actions would give ICE agents real terror of being gunned down."
Powderly wrote that agency reports of a "significant increase in ICE activity and threats against ICE" led Apple to review ICE-tracking apps again. Apple concluded that sharing "precise location information about ICE officers" could also expose people near them, such as protesters or detainees. It said such information provides "a potential roadmap for targeted violence and creating a significant risk of harm." According to Powderly, the company "does not take decisions about removing apps from the App Store lightly, but acts when it must."

Analysis
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and FBI Director Kash Patel have said the Dallas shooting showed that ICE agents were being targeted. Patel also said the shooter "searched for apps that tracked ICE agents' locations." At the time of the attack, Nancy Larson, the US attorney for the Northern District of Texas, called it a "tragic irony" that a detainee was killed.
Raskin told Apple there is "no evidence" the shooter used an ICE-tracking app. He added that even if the shooter had searched for one, "he did not need a tracking app to locate the fixed position of a government building." Raskin wrote that the shooter "is reported to have found the address using an app that comes standard on Apple devices" and that there "appears to be no direct connection" between the attack and the removed apps.
DHS also often cites an internal statistic from October 2025 that claims an 8,000 percent increase in death threats against ICE officers. The agency has not released the data behind that figure, so outside groups cannot check it.
The letter feeds into a lawsuit filed by ICEBlock's creator, Joshua Aaron, against Trump administration officials. Aaron alleges that officials censored people who monitor the government and that they publicly bragged about getting his app removed. Pam Bondi, then the attorney general, publicly said she made the "demand" and that "Apple did so."
In a court filing, Aaron said Apple had first decided to keep ICEBlock after what he called a thorough five-week legal review. According to his filing, Apple then reversed that decision, citing only "information provided to Apple by law enforcement," and Bondi described Apple's response as "compliance." Ars Technica noted that Apple's July letter to Raskin, which cited agency reports, seemed to confirm that officials played a role.
Federal officials say Apple acted on its own. The administration has asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit. It argues that officials' public remarks were only opinions about apps it considers dangerous. It also says Aaron has found no communication that could be "reasonably understood to convey a threat of adverse government action" against Apple if the company kept ICEBlock available.
In a recent filing, Aaron pointed to an August ruling by the Second Circuit, a federal appeals court. The ruling upheld that courts broadly recognize "a First Amendment right to record law enforcement activity in public." According to Ars Technica, that argument could influence how the court decides the case at this early stage.
Aaron expects the case to move forward. According to Ars Technica, if it does, discovery would likely reveal the actual communications between government officials and Apple leadership. So far those communications have not been made public. Aaron argues that only then can a court decide whether "a threat of adverse government action" led to the removals.
Aaron did not comment directly on CNN's report. On Bluesky, he shared an ICEBlock post that thanked Raskin for continuing to press Apple. The post said Apple is "sticking to their story even though everyone can see this was jawboning plain as day." Jawboning means government pressure on a company to limit speech. Raskin, for his part, wrote that monitoring federal immigration authorities in one's neighborhood "is a core First Amendment right and not a crime."
Task-force chair Jay Clayton says a risk study and three committees will help put voluntary company safety commitments into practice.
5 min

DeepSeek says its new 552-billion-parameter model's cache needs much less memory than the previous generation's and beats V4-Pro in tests. The company says V4-Pro requests are due to route to it from September 14 and has changed its API prices. The test claims come from DeepSeek itself.
4 min

The security firm Mindgard says it got past the safety limits on two of Moonshot's Kimi models. It has not tested whether the answers would work. Moonshot says it is reviewing the findings and that its own tests show the models usually refuse such requests.
4 min
Correction ·
House style applied: Armenian punctuation, date and money forms.
Correction ·
Corrected spelling and punctuation in the Armenian text.
Correction ·
Corrected the wording of the English version.
Correction ·
Clarified wording so the article attributes claims to their sources.