Breathing out linked to faster responses in a button-clicking test

Responses in 35 volunteers averaged 41 milliseconds faster during exhalation than inhalation. Earlier memory and recognition tests found the opposite pattern.

Responses in 35 volunteers averaged 41 milliseconds faster during exhalation than inhalation. Earlier memory and recognition tests found the opposite pattern.
People responded to a simple visual cue an average of 41 milliseconds faster while breathing out than while breathing in, in an experiment with 35 volunteers. Science News reported the finding on September 30, following the researchers’ September 28 report in the journal iScience.
Researchers Ken Paller and Erika Yamazaki, then at Northwestern University, used the reaction-time test to assess how sleepy the volunteers were. Participants clicked a button when a red square on a screen turned yellow. Short tubes in their noses recorded breathing throughout the task, allowing the researchers to compare responses during inhalation, or breathing in, and exhalation, or breathing out.
The exhalation–inhalation difference held regardless of how sleepy or alert the volunteers were. Volunteers also responded faster while holding their breath than while breathing in.
A 2016 study found the opposite pattern: responses were faster during inhalation than exhalation in tests of recall and facial recognition. Those tests involved more than waiting for a simple cue.
Paller says the earlier tasks required more mental processing. Participants might have to judge whether a face looked fearful or surprised, rather than simply react to a colour change. He cautions that these different tasks may not have the same relationship with breathing.
Why breathing and response speed were linked remains unclear. Paller points to earlier studies suggesting that breathing is synchronized with brain waves—the rhythms of brain activity—as a possible explanation. That is not an established mechanism for the button-clicking result.
The 41-millisecond figure describes an average in this group, not a guaranteed gain for every person or every response. Whether repeat experiments would reproduce the same difference remains unclear. The button-clicking result also does not establish that timing a breath would improve a sprinter’s start.

Businesses with more than 50 employees face restrictions on promoting certain foods high in fat, sugar or salt. Ordinary discounts and meal-deal offers remain allowed.
2 min

QATCH aims to develop and compare software across quantum machines, using UK national testbeds to work towards practical benefits.
3 min

Taxes would replace insurance premiums and out-of-pocket charges, while one fund would pay healthcare providers. Who pays less—or more—depends on decisions still ahead.
4 min