California prosecutors sue to block 548 death sentence commutations


Victims' advocates joined the November 16 petition against Governor Gavin Newsom’s plan to replace death sentences with life without parole. The state Supreme Court also faces a separate request to recommend many of the changes.
California prosecutors and victims' advocates petitioned the state Supreme Court on 16 November to stop Governor Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute the death sentences of 548 people. A commutation changes a sentence without overturning the conviction.
Newsom announced the plan on 5 November, saying he would replace every California death sentence with life in prison without the possibility of parole. His office says the changes will not take effect until the necessary legal steps are complete. Newsom said he had a moral imperative to oppose state-sanctioned killings.
Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019 and later ordered the dismantling of the execution chamber at San Quentin State Prison.
The petitioners say Newsom was required to give district attorneys and victims' families notice and a chance to provide input before granting clemency. The Guardian says prosecutors from 30 counties joined victims' relatives and advocacy groups in the challenge.
The Guardian reports that district attorneys from 30 of California’s 58 counties filed the challenge. CalMatters, in a correction, put the number at 29 counties.
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation says it filed the lawsuit on behalf of, among others, law enforcement leaders and organizations. It also argues that the plan abuses clemency power because it lacks meaningful individual reviews.
By predetermining the outcome for every inmate on death row, the Governor has abandoned his responsibility to exercise meaningful discretion.

Gavin Newsom issued blanket commutations to life without parole, a change from his earlier halt on executions. Some grants require court approval before they become final.
Newsom says the notice requirement applies when a prisoner applies for a commutation, not when the governor initiates clemency. He said his office would notify the district attorneys after submitting the proposed commutations to the court and seek their help notifying victims.
The plan has divided prosecutors and victims' families. The Santa Clara and Contra Costa district attorneys support it, saying the death penalty is outdated, ineffective and costly. Polly Klaas’s sisters also support the changes, calling for an approach that supports healing and prevents harm rather than treating survivors' pain as permission for state killing; her father, Marc Klaas, joined the petition against them.
Newsom has separately asked the Supreme Court to recommend clemency for 382 people with multiple felony convictions. California’s constitution requires a recommendation from 4 justices before their sentences can be commuted.
The Habeas Corpus Resource Center says Newsom has not yet formally commuted any sentences. After any required court recommendation, he would still have to issue commutation certificates for the changes to take effect. For people without a separate felony conviction, the center says, he can commute sentences unilaterally.
In that separate request, the court has invited briefs from interested parties on the legal issues. Proposed briefs are due 24 November, and Newsom’s combined response is due 4 December.
1 min