California agencies split over tribal marine-protection proposals


The commission’s October vote could advance new protected areas and tribal harvest rules, but approval and shared management remain unsettled.
Two California agencies disagree over whether to create new tribal marine protected areas, while generally backing requests for tribal harvest exemptions, Inside Climate News reported on October 2. The California Fish and Game Commission is scheduled to vote on recommendations to advance or deny the tribal petitions in the week of October 15. The petitions have not yet been approved.
California has 125 marine protected areas—underwater parks established to protect and enhance biodiversity, the variety of living things. The state opened a petition process to change the network in 2023. Five of the 20 petitions received are tribally led or co-led, introducing government-to-government consultation into a system whose guiding law, the Marine Life Protection Act, passed in 1999 without tribes as formal stakeholders.
| Request | Petitions | Agency recommendations |
|---|---|---|
| Create new marine protected areas | 3 | Fish and Wildlife recommends denial; the Ocean Protection Council recommends approval of all but one proposal. |
| Allow tribal harvest of specific species without creating new protected areas | 2 | Both agencies generally recommend approval. |
The Department of Fish and Wildlife manages the protected areas and evaluates proposals under a framework the commission established in 2009. That framework specifies scientific measures and ecological spacing requirements for protected areas. The sets policy priorities for the network and uses more flexible criteria to advance the Marine Life Protection Act.

An Eos comparison traces hillside failures into river channels and the bay after heavy rain in North Korea. Clouds and delayed access to imagery limit the initial assessment.
Council executive director Jenn Eckerle told Inside Climate News that its assessment used a precautionary approach: considering worsening climate scenarios when deciding what protections to recommend. She said the council’s recommendations were intended to complement Fish and Wildlife’s evaluations, which addressed different questions and criteria.
Sandy Aylesworth, a Pacific Initiative director at the Natural Resources Defense Council, praised the council’s approach as using the best available science to strengthen climate resilience and protect vulnerable habitats, including persistent kelp forests. She criticized Fish and Wildlife’s recommendations as entrenching past decisions.
Near the Oregon border, the Tolowa Dee-ni’ Nation wants harvesting of true smelt restricted to tribal harvest within the existing Pyramid Point State Marine Conservation Area. The fish have been declining for years, Inside Climate News reported. Rachel McCain, the Nation’s Natural Resource Department director, said traditional harvest is tied to culture and identity, not simply catching fish.
The Santa Ynez Band of Chumash Indians has proposed three new protected-area sites. One, Mishopshno in Santa Barbara, includes the site of the Chumash creation story and traditional canoe-building sites. The proposal therefore concerns culturally important places as well as marine resources.
Instead of the proposed new tribal marine protected areas, Fish and Wildlife suggested exploring a designation under state parks called State Marine Cultural Preservation Areas. These are intended to protect non-living cultural heritage sites. California has never established or managed one, so how the designation would be implemented remains unclear.
Violet Sage Walker, chairwoman of the Northern Chumash Tribal Council, criticized that suggestion as passing the decision to another agency. She said state parks had not said whether it could or would implement the designation.
2 min

NHS England’s review found consent procedures did not follow its digital principles. Its guidance calls for decisions for each patient, rather than blanket use of monitoring technology.
4 min

Regulator records describe oil and chemical releases. A September 2024 spill closed local cockle beds for five weeks and remains under criminal investigation.
3 min
Correction ·
Corrected spelling and punctuation in the Armenian text.