Study finds different resource pressures across climate pathways

A comparison of 24 modeled pathways found that similar warming outcomes can place very different demands on land, water and minerals, depending on the energy technologies used.
In this article
Climate pathways that produce similar levels of warming can put very different pressures on land, water and minerals, a study in Nature Energy found. Its comparison offers a way to weigh those demands when choosing energy infrastructure.
The researchers examined 24 modeled pathways with different assumptions about social and economic development, climate ambition and energy systems. They combined those pathways with an assessment of the environmental impacts of future technologies, Phys.org said.
Land, minerals and water
Energy-system land use ranged from a 13% decrease to a 354% increase across the pathways. The use of biomass strongly influenced the result.
More ambitious pathways required more minerals in the near term. Less ambitious pathways ultimately needed similar levels of resources over the long term and demanded more energy, as their shift to more efficient electrified processes came later.
Water use rose in nearly all pathways. The study linked the increase to demand for water in mining, material processing and cooling across expanding electricity supply chains.
Assessing future technologies
Alvaro Jose Hahn Menacho of the PSI Laboratory for Energy Systems Analysis led the study. Co-author Romain Sacchi, also at the laboratory, developed Premise, an open-source tool that made assessments of future technologies’ environmental impacts more accessible.
The results describe modeled alternatives rather than a single predicted outcome. They can help policymakers compare resource pressures alongside climate goals before committing to major infrastructure investments.
Follow AveNews
Earlier in Science
SpaceResearchers detect oxygen from simulated lunar soil using plasma
The laboratory experiment adapted a semiconductor manufacturing process, but the team says yields must rise substantially before it could be practical on the Moon.
2 min
EarthChina and Australia welcome 35% global electrification goal
Their November 20 statement backs a voluntary ambition for electricity to reach that share of final energy use by 2035, without setting national targets.
2 min
EarthInternational Maritime Organization tracks $10.5 billion in marine climate funds
The incomplete total covers 2018–2023 and represents 0.14% of global climate finance. The maritime organization estimates that cutting international shipping emissions and building shore infrastructure will require $1.2 trillion to $1.6 trillion by 2050.
3 min
