Dinosaur Jr.’s uneasy partnership has produced six reunion albums


With the new album There Near, Pitchfork’s interviews explore the trio’s distinctive sound and how musical agreement has sustained collaboration despite continuing personal friction.
Dinosaur Jr.’s original trio reunited for a few shows in 2005. That tentative return grew into six new albums, Pitchfork reports, despite continuing personal friction between J Mascis, bassist Lou Barlow and drummer Murph.
The magazine’s September 29 feature, published around the new album There Near, offers one explanation through Barlow’s account: he separates his belief in Mascis’ musical ideas from the difficulties of getting along with him.
I’ve never had musical differences with J
For Barlow, the music’s quality mattered more than the personal problems. That distinction helps explain his continued commitment without suggesting that all three musicians have resolved their differences.
Mascis and Barlow first played together in the hardcore band Deep Wound, with Mascis on drums. Murph recalls watching Mascis play solos that mixed jazz and hardcore, then admiring Deep Wound’s determination to become the fastest hardcore band around.
After Deep Wound split, Mascis switched to guitar for the new band. Barlow remembers the aim as music that was heavy without being metal. Pitchfork describes Mascis’ Dinosaur Jr. playing as combining extreme volume with memorable melodies.
The instrumental relationship was deliberate. Barlow played high up the bass neck, producing higher notes that pushed against Mascis’ lead guitar. Mascis also wrote the drum parts for Murph to play. Barlow credits Mascis with devising the bass-and-guitar interplay and says he completely believed in it.

Another Planet Entertainment took over the underused San Francisco hall in 2010. Repairs, stronger rigging and retractable seating helped adapt the historic building to different kinds of performances.
The trio released three records between 1985 and 1988: its self-titled debut, You’re Living All Over Me and Bug. But the musicians’ shared work did not keep their relationship from deteriorating.
Pitchfork recounts an onstage fight in Connecticut in which Mascis believed Barlow was deliberately ruining a song. Barlow rejects that explanation: “I would never do that,” he told the magazine. “The only thing holding us together was the songs.”
Mascis eventually fired Barlow, ending the original lineup’s first run. Pitchfork describes the split as bitter and reports that their public feud lasted until 2005. Asked whether he had expected to play with Mascis again, Barlow answered, “Not really, no.”
Reissues brought the original trio back together for a handful of shows in 2005. The subsequent albums made that return more than a chance to revisit the early records. Yet Pitchfork’s account does not present their longevity as a complete personal reconciliation: the friction persists alongside the renewed collaboration.
3 min

Signing in alone will no longer guarantee access to Old Reddit. Moderators will be exempt from the recent-use rule, but RSS users face a separate November 13 cutoff.
2 min

The album documents her first orchestral performance, a 2025 London concert mixing solo songs with Breeders material. A Cuán Roche-directed film will accompany it.
2 min