Racing Bulls opposes Williams’s Formula 1 spending reform

The Race says Williams looks unlikely to secure enough backing for 2027. Racing Bulls’ boss rejects wholesale changes but leaves room for smaller tweaks.

The Race says Williams looks unlikely to secure enough backing for 2027. Racing Bulls’ boss rejects wholesale changes but leaves room for smaller tweaks.
Racing Bulls opposes Williams’s plan to give trailing Formula 1 teams more spending freedom. Its opposition makes Williams likely to fall short of the critical sixth team vote needed for a 2027 change, The Race reports on 9 October.
The proposed allowance would give teams trailing in the championship more spending freedom. Vowles argues that the current cap locks in leading teams’ earlier investments: The Race reports that depreciation charges for improving facilities also draw on each season’s running and development budget, limiting the resources available to catch up.
Formula 1’s cost cap, which limits team spending, began in 2021. At a press conference on 2 October, Williams team principal James Vowles proposed linking extra spending room to championship points or position so trailing teams could move closer to the leaders over time. He credits the cap with improving financial stability and wants to change it, not abolish it.
The Race reports broad support for the concept from Cadillac, Aston Martin, Audi and Alpine, alongside Williams. These are indications of support, not formal votes. Both possible start years also require approval from Formula 1 management and motorsport’s governing body, the FIA.
| Start year | Support required | Voting threshold |
|---|---|---|
| 2027 | FIA, FOM and six of the current 11 teams | Supermajority |
| 2028 | FIA, FOM and four teams | Simple majority |
Racing Bulls team principal Alan Permane told The Race at the Singapore Grand Prix that he would not support wholesale cost-cap changes allowing teams to spend much more, though he left room for smaller tweaks. He argues that existing rules already allow substantial capital investment—spending on assets such as factory equipment—with the expenditure paid off over subsequent years.
The Race reports that Haas opposes changes because it believes the current system works as intended. Its 7 October report also said sources suggested Haas opposed the proposal because it spends below the existing cap and extra spending freedom would help its rivals.
The proposal is expected to go to a team vote at the next F1 Commission meeting, planned for November, The Race reports. No rule change has been approved.
Analysis
The Race checked Mercedes, Ferrari, Red Bull and McLaren—the four teams Vowles identifies—regardless of their championship positions. Its calculations confirm his rounded figures for their points share after the cap and for the decline in other teams’ share of podium finishes, meaning finishes in the first three places.
| Measure | Before the cap | After the cap began |
|---|---|---|
| Mercedes, Ferrari, Red Bull and McLaren’s combined points share | 77% in 2011–20, according to Vowles | 83.5% in the five completed seasons, 2021–25 |
| Other teams’ share of podium finishes | 10.5% in 2011–20 | 5.4% since the cap began, in the 9 October check |
Those four names do not always mean the four highest-placed teams. McLaren finished outside the championship’s top four seven times from 2013 to 2022; Mercedes missed that group in 2012 and Ferrari in 2020. The Race says McLaren’s weaker results in the 2010s lowered the named group’s earlier average, while its return to the front raised that group’s points share.
Counting each season’s four highest-placed teams instead, The Race found a broadly consistent points share, generally leaving about 17% for everyone else. The fixed-team comparison therefore partly reflects McLaren’s changing performance. These before-and-after shares do not by themselves establish that the cap caused greater dominance.
The Race nevertheless concludes that the hoped-for catch-up effect is not happening: other teams have occasionally entered the top four without becoming consistent contenders for wins over several seasons. Alpine was the latest entrant in 2022; the same team reached that group as Renault in 2018 and Lotus in 2012 and 2013. Williams and the team now called Aston Martin, under its Force India and Racing Point names, have also entered it.
In comments reported by Crash.net on 2 October, Vowles said Williams spends millions, even tens of millions, on basic factory systems such as tracking parts. That money cannot also fund a front wing or another car upgrade. He argues that buying tools better-equipped rivals already have forces Williams to choose between immediate improvements and longer-term capabilities. The precise accounting treatment of that systems spending remains unclear.
Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff opposes a sliding scale of extra spending freedom for lower-performing teams. He argues that teams such as Mercedes, which invested heavily in the past, must count large depreciation charges—the portion of those investment costs charged each year—against the cap, limiting their annual operating budgets. In his view, teams that invested less previously have more room to spend on infrastructure now.
Wolff nevertheless sees grounds for other cost-cap changes. He says the cap suppresses salaries, leaving specialists with doctorates and five to seven years of experience earning less than they could at technology companies, hedge funds or investment banks. In his view, that makes it harder for teams to retain their best talent against competition from other industries.
Motorsport Week reported on 7 October that Williams was ninth in the teams’ championship with 12 points, after finishing fifth in 2025, when Carlos Sainz took podium finishes in Baku and Qatar. Williams missed the first winter test of 2026 and began the season with a significantly overweight car. Vowles accepted responsibility for the winter mistakes and said Williams sacrificed aerodynamic development—improvements to airflow around the car—to fund elements needed for 2027, leaving potential gains from wind-tunnel testing unused.
The Baku upgrade brought Williams its best qualifying result of the year, with Sainz ninth on the grid, and its first point since Monaco. Vowles said the car was carrying ballast, or added weight, indicating progress on its weight problem, but that the improvement came too late in the season. Williams plans to reuse the chassis—the car’s central structure—introduced at the Azerbaijan Grand Prix for 2027, considerably reducing winter work.
Vowles also pointed to changes in software and working practices and to Piers Thynne, the former McLaren chief operating officer who joined Williams in August as chief optimisation and planning officer. Sainz and Alex Albon have committed to Williams for 2027. Motorsport Week cautioned that a lighter winter workload does not prove the failed production processes have been repaired; a comparable test comes when Williams next builds a car from scratch. Vowles said the first race of 2027 would reveal how successful the wind-tunnel and systems development had been.
At the 2 October press conference, Ferrari team principal Frédéric Vasseur pointed to existing results-linked wind-tunnel allowances, which Vowles agreed were a step in the right direction. Vasseur recalled five or six teams being bankrupt or close to bankruptcy in 2016–2018. Vowles said the cap had achieved and exceeded its financial-sustainability goal, while arguing that its goals of fairer competition and a closer field had failed.
Alpine’s Flavio Briatore supported the cap’s purpose but proposed including all spending, whatever the overall limit, to reduce the administrative burden of deciding what counts. Vowles called that one possible direction; it is not an adopted rule.
The Race reported on 7 October that Vowles wants an allowance introduced in 2027, with effects emerging over about three years before the next rules cycle in either 2030 or 2031. Its 9 October account describes a points-based measure that would give teams behind in the constructors’ championship—the competition between teams—greater spending freedom.
These are three possible designs described by The Race on 7 October, not agreed terms. The allowance’s scale would depend on discussions in the F1 Commission or Formula 1’s Financial Advisory Committee; its design and start year remain undecided.

The proposal would make SAMBO Europe FIAS’s only recognized continental federation in Europe. Final approval requires a Congress vote.
2 min

Michelin’s recommendation was not compulsory. Riders first tried the reinforced-casing tyre in Sunday’s extended warm-up and reported unexpectedly strong grip.
3 min

The South African beat Tomoya Tsuboi by split decision in Tokyo in his first professional fight outside his home country.
2 min
| Period | Combined points share |
|---|---|
| 2021 through the ongoing 2026 season | 84.1% |
| 2026 season to the date of the check | 87.7% |