Texas city quotes $2.3 million for records on police use of Flock

Records requests have exposed misuse of the vehicle-tracking system, but disclosure charges vary widely and optional transparency portals do not always make data public.

Records requests have exposed misuse of the vehicle-tracking system, but disclosure charges vary widely and optional transparency portals do not always make data public.
North Richland Hills, a Fort Worth suburb, quoted the Texas Privacy Coalition $2.3 million to fulfill a public-records request for Flock data, Ars Technica reported on October 5, citing the Texas Tribune. The charge would put a substantial price on access to records of a kind that has helped expose police misuse.
Flock supplies automated license-plate readers: cameras that record the plates of passing vehicles. Police can search the resulting database to track vehicle movements. Flock says its readers are designed for public safety.
City officials attributed the estimate to searching about a terabyte of communications concerning Flock errors, misuse and effectiveness. They said the work would require approximately 14 years of labor at $15 an hour.
The requester, using the pseudonym Phil Mynona on behalf of the Texas Privacy Coalition, told the Tribune the fee seemed “ludicrous” and designed to stifle his records searches. That was his assessment; intentional obstruction is not established. Mynona said he had sought similar records from more than 200 US law-enforcement agencies and could not predict how cities would assess charges.
| Agency or requester | Reported charge or estimate |
|---|---|
| North Richland Hills | $2.3 million estimate |
| Some cities responding to Mynona | More than 400,000 pages supplied free |
| Other cities responding to Mynona | $5,000 charged |
| Other requesters, including Houston news station KPRC | Quotes reaching $121,000 |
Ars reported that a USA Today public-records request exposed Flock misuse by former Texas officer Zachary Anthony Klein and another officer, prompting an investigation followed by Klein’s arrest. According to the October 5 report, Klein pleaded guilty the previous week to 100 felony counts of misuse of official information, in exchange for the state not pursuing charges related to stalking several people.
The Tribune also reported that Texas Governor Greg Abbott halted Flock funding and stopped issuing permits in response to the case, according to Ars.
Separate legal scrutiny has focused on the grounds for searching the database. Ars, citing 404 Media, reported that a federal judge in Oklahoma ruled a search unconstitutional after an officer searched solely because a woman’s license plate was from California. Ars said the ruling does not set precedent.
Costs are not the only barrier to access. According to the Tribune reporting recounted by Ars, the Texas Department of Public Safety asked the Attorney General’s Office for permission to withhold all Flock data requested by the Tribune. The department had previously responded to an identical request covering earlier weeks. Whether it will be allowed to withhold the records remains unresolved.
Flock offers optional transparency portals through which police agencies can voluntarily publish information about their camera programs. The portals can show camera counts, vehicles scanned and police searches. Flock spokesperson Andrew Smith told the Tribune they also let agencies publish policies, usage information and access rules.
Hundreds of Texas agencies use Flock cameras, but only 59 use transparency portals, and just 16 of those share data publicly, the Tribune reported, according to Ars. Having a portal therefore does not necessarily give residents access to information about how their police agency uses the system.

The company says most apps work smoothly, but some complex apps and games built for Arm chips need extra work on Intel models.
2 min


The proposed bills would require outside validation, impose $25,000-per-violation fines and let residents sue over foreseeable harms from tools whose safeguards are bypassed.
2 min
The models, released on September 30, accept text and images. Cohere positions Pro for quality-critical indexing and the cheaper Fast for live searches.
3 min