Forest-floor removal left soil carbon depleted 20 years after logging

An experiment at 12 British Columbia sites found more stable soil carbon where logging left the organic surface layer intact.

An experiment at 12 British Columbia sites found more stable soil carbon where logging left the organic surface layer intact.
Keeping the forest floor intact helped limit soil-carbon losses after logging in a long-term British Columbia experiment. Where both logging residue and the forest floor were removed, total soil carbon remained 33% below its preharvest level 20 years later, Wallace and colleagues reported, according to Eos.
The forest floor is the layer of organic material above the mineral soil beneath it. Preserving carbon in these layers matters because forest soils hold an estimated 40% of the world’s terrestrial carbon, Eos notes. Soil carbon is only part of a forest’s carbon store; these results do not measure the change in carbon across the entire ecosystem.
The researchers analyzed 12 sites in the British Columbia Long-Term Soil Productivity experiment. The sites spanned four regions with different climate and vegetation, and each had reached 20 years after harvesting. Each site contained nine treatment plots testing different levels of organic-material removal and soil compaction—the pressing together of soil.
Researchers sampled the forest floor and mineral soil before harvesting, then again after 5, 10 and 20 years. Those repeated measurements tracked losses and recovery against each site’s preharvest carbon levels.
| Treatment | Carbon measured | Years after harvest | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forest floor kept intact | Forest-floor carbon | 20 | 5% decrease |
| Forest floor kept intact | Mineral-soil carbon | 20 | 14% increase |
| Harvest residue and forest floor removed | Total soil carbon | 5 | 52% decrease |
| Harvest residue and forest floor removed | Total soil carbon | 20 | 33% decrease |
The researchers also reported that stem-only harvesting preserved about 15% more forest-floor carbon than whole-tree harvesting. That comparison concerns carbon in the organic surface layer, not total carbon in the soil or forest.
Analysis
For sites where the forest floor was fully removed, the researchers estimated that soil carbon would take 22–86 years to return to preharvest levels. These are projected recovery times, distinct from the measured 20-year outcomes. How precise those estimates are, and how strongly they depend on the assumptions used to calculate them, remains unclear.
The results should not be treated as a timetable for every forest. Eos notes that wildfire, insects, disease and past forest management can affect soil-carbon stores, while tree type, climate and harvesting method can affect losses.
For timber harvesting, the authors draw a practical lesson: retain organic residue and protect the forest floor from heavy disturbance to help preserve soil carbon. At the sites stripped of both, two decades of recovery still left a substantial carbon deficit.

Hospital responses describe prolonged painkiller shortages and higher spending to secure a blood-pressure drug. The figures cover responding trusts, not hospitals nationwide.
3 min

The light-control technique was used with gene delivery and special goggles in a vision trial. The result in one man does not establish a generally effective treatment.

The agency reports no evidence of ongoing transmission, but the unconfirmed diagnosis prevents it from judging whether Russia’s seven-day contact monitoring was sufficient.
8 min