New York judge lets Bich heirs’ Fra Angelico lawsuit proceed

The October 26 decision, filed 16 November, dismisses claims against art dealer Richard Feigen’s trust but allows claims against his estate and businesses to continue over Saint Sixtus.
In this article
New York Supreme Court Justice James G. Clynes has rejected an attempt by art dealer Richard Feigen’s estate and associated businesses to dismiss a lawsuit by the heirs to the Bic pen fortune over Fra Angelico’s Saint Sixtus. The brothers allege that their family chauffeur stole the painting and sold it to Feigen for $3 million.
Clynes dismissed claims against Feigen’s revocable trust and its trustees because the brothers had not sufficiently connected the trust to the sale proceeds. They can bring those claims again if they find more evidence. The judge has not decided whether the painting was stolen or who owns it, ARTnews said.
The painting’s disputed path
Saint Sixtus is a tempera painting on a wooden panel made around 1453–55 by Fra Angelico, an Italian Dominican friar and Renaissance painter. It is believed to be among his last works. Bic founder Marcel Bich bought it at Sotheby’s in 1972 for £130,000 (about $170,000). It passed to his son Bruno, who kept it in his Manhattan apartment. According to the brothers’ complaint, Bruno placed it in trust for his sons Gonzalve, Charles and Guillaume.
- Around 2006, the painting disappeared. The brothers allege that chauffeur Roy Morrow stole it and sold it to Feigen for $3 million.
- In 2018, after Feigen consigned it to auction house Christie’s, the painting sold for $5.4 million to Álvaro Saieh and Ana Guzmán.
- The brothers say they learned where it was in 2023 and demanded its return in 2024. Saieh and Guzmán refused, and the brothers sued in March 2026.
The brothers allege that Morrow had no paperwork proving ownership and that Feigen insured the painting for $8.5 million, nearly three times what he paid. Their complaint alleges Feigen should have recognized it was stolen. Feigen’s estate lawyers have said Morrow signed a bill of sale stating that he owned it. Saieh and Guzmán say they bought the painting in good faith, relying on Christie’s research.
Analysis
Why the claims can continue
Feigen’s lawyers argued that the family waited too long to sue. Clynes said unanswered questions about Feigen’s purchase prevented him from deciding the time-limit issue at this stage. He also rejected, for now, the argument known as laches: that the delay made it unfair to let the case continue. Both arguments can be raised again.
In a 1991 decision, New York’s Court of Appeals said an owner can recover stolen property even from a buyer who purchased it in good faith. The court described a three-year period for seeking its return that, in such a case, begins when the owner demands it and the buyer refuses. It also said an owner’s efforts to find the property can matter to a laches defense and that prejudice must also be shown.
The brothers seek the painting’s return from Saieh and Guzmán, as well as sale proceeds and damages from Feigen’s side. Their complaint says they also demanded the proceeds from Isabelle Harnoncourt-Feigen, Feigen’s widow and estate executor. Family lawyer Luke Nikas called the decision an important step toward recovering the painting.
Follow AveNews
Earlier in Culture
MusicMusic charts: Olivia Rodrigo’s “Stupid Song” tops Pop Airplay
The track climbs from No. 4 on Billboard’s Pop Airplay chart, becoming the singer’s fourth leader and the second from her third album, you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love.
1 min
SoftwareBrickLink targets November 24 return after marketplace outage
The LEGO resale site went offline on 19 November while its team investigated unusual activity. Its reopening target depends on the investigation and work to restore service safely.
2 min
MusicThe Mars Volta releases fan-selected live album
LUCRO SUCIO; UNFINISHED BUSINESS draws on the band’s 2025 US tour and is its first official live record since 2005’s Scabdates.
2 min
Sources
ARTnewsJudge Allows Lawsuit Over Allegedly Stolen Fra Angelico to Move Forward (opens in a new tab)
- independent.co.ukHeirs to Bic pen fortune accuse family chauffeur of stealing 500-year-old painting | The Independent (opens in a new tab)
- law.cornell.eduTHE SOLOMON R. GUGGENHEIM FOUNDATION, RESPONDENT, v. MRS. JULES LUBELL, APPELLANT. (THIRD & FOURTH-PARTY ACTIONS.) (opens in a new tab)
