Why Germany’s regional champions can miss out on promotion


Lokomotive Leipzig has won three titles without moving up. A plan to give every champion a promotion place remains disputed, with a federation meeting set for 18 December.
Lokomotive Leipzig won Germany’s Regional League Northeast in 2020, 2025 and again this summer, but none of those titles brought promotion. The club’s repeated disappointment illustrates a problem that German football has yet to resolve: five fourth-tier leagues produce five champions, but only four can move up each season.
As BBC Sport explains, four clubs are relegated from the nationwide 3. Liga, Germany’s third division, creating four vacancies. The fourth tier below it is divided into North, West, Southwest, Northeast and Bavaria. The West and Southwest champions receive automatic promotion. A third automatic place rotates among the other three leagues on a three-year cycle, leaving the remaining two champions to contest a play-off for the last place.
For Leipzig, that meant a play-off against Bavaria’s Wurzburger Kickers this summer. Captain Djamal Ziane scored, but Leipzig, weakened by injuries, lost 3–1 on aggregate—the combined score across the play-off matches. Winning the league had earned the club another chance at promotion, not promotion itself.
The West and Southwest receive guaranteed places because their regions have more registered men’s football teams, reflecting their larger populations. That leaves clubs elsewhere seeking a system in which every league title leads directly to the division above.
Clubs launched a reform campaign in March 2025 under the slogan “Champions must go up”. Their proposed “compass model” would reduce the fourth tier to four leagues, matching the four promotion places. Superintelligence would help redraw the geographical boundaries each season, taking account of travel distances and local rivalry matches.
The proposal would require regions to accept changes to their existing competitions. Its northeastern supporters are prepared to give up a league boundary tied to the former East Germany. More than 80 clubs across Germany have backed the campaign, including Bundesliga club Union Berlin.
Before clubs voted at the end of June, the regional federations conducting the ballot announced two last-minute changes, BBC Sport reports. The four proposed leagues would each contain 18 teams rather than 20, reducing the available places. Approval would also require a majority in each of the five existing regions, not just an overall majority.
The compass model received 50.9% support overall, with majorities in the West, North and Northeast. But the Southwest backed an alternative that would dissolve the northeastern league and redistribute its clubs while leaving the West and Southwest unchanged. Bavaria voted for further talks. The required agreement across all five regions was therefore not reached.
Opposition includes concern about how clubs would be assigned to leagues. Robert Lempka, chief executive of Southwest club FSV Frankfurt, told public broadcaster Hessischer Rundfunk that he considered the proposed system more complex and economically risky, according to BBC Sport. “I find it unsettling that an untransparent algorithm should decide a club’s future,” he said. An algorithm is a set of rules a computer follows to make a calculation or decision.
Bavarian Football Federation president Christoph Kern also resisted abandoning the existing Bavarian league. He told Munich’s Abendzeitung newspaper in August that none of the suggested models had majority support among his clubs, BBC Sport reports.
The unresolved dispute has prompted protests this season. In the Northeast, almost every match has begun with players refusing to play for the first minute. Leipzig supporters threw hundreds of plastic trophies onto the pitch on the opening day to express their frustration at winning consecutive titles without promotion.
BBC Sport reports that the German Football Federation, known as the DFB, has announced an extraordinary general meeting for 18 December. DFB president Bernd Neuendorf said the issue must be resolved and argued that the compass model offered the best chance to concentrate high-level competition and improve talent development. Reform remains unsettled, however, and any changes would take effect only in the 2028–29 season. Until then, a regional championship will still not guarantee promotion.

Tampa Bay’s decision to replace its goalkeeper with an extra attacker gave Igor Shesterkin an empty net to aim at in New York’s 5–1 home-opening win.
2 min

Players can use negotiated contract protections to narrow their destinations after requesting a trade. Bettman questioned that use; agent Allan Walsh said clubs freely agree to the clauses.
2 min

Clubs qualify only if a new injury keeps a player out for at least 28 continuous days. Payments cover salary, not bonuses, and have daily and total limits.
3 min