Giants add J.J. McCarthy, but Jameis Winston remains starter


New York sent Minnesota a 2027 fifth-round pick to add depth after Jaxson Dart’s knee surgery. Coach John Harbaugh confirmed the trade would not change Winston’s role.
The New York Giants acquired quarterback J.J. McCarthy from the Minnesota Vikings on September 28 for a 2027 fifth-round draft pick, ESPN reports. The deal adds depth after Jaxson Dart’s left-knee surgery; his season ended in Week 2 with major tears in that knee. Giants coach John Harbaugh confirmed after the trade that Jameis Winston would remain the starter.
In his September 28 analysis, ESPN’s Eric Karabell argues that uncertainty over Dart’s ability to stay healthy for a full season makes the trade sensible. Concussions also affected Dart’s rookie season. Karabell still describes Dart as the Giants’ future quarterback, so the acquisition is not necessarily a move to replace him.
McCarthy is 23 and was selected No. 10 in the 2024 NFL draft. But his own career has been interrupted by injury: he missed his entire rookie season with a knee injury.
His first active season was difficult. McCarthy completed 57.6% of his passes and threw more interceptions—passes caught by opponents—than touchdown passes. New York is therefore adding a young quarterback who still needs to establish that he can perform well when healthy, rather than a proven replacement for Dart.
Giants coach John Harbaugh said after the team’s Week 3 win over the Titans that Jameis Winston would remain the starting quarterback even if New York added another quarterback. He reiterated that position on September 28 after the McCarthy trade, ESPN reports.
Winston led New York to a 12–7 win over the Titans on the Sunday before Karabell’s analysis. He threw for 118 yards in difficult weather and avoided turnovers.

The decision was adopted at a September 27 sports council meeting in Almaty, Kazakhstan. Yerevan will also become the CIS Sports Capital.
Karabell sees possible starts for McCarthy later in 2026, or the following season if Dart’s health limits him. Those possible future starts are not settled, and Karabell cautions against assuming McCarthy will perform well. The trade gives the Giants another option; whether McCarthy earns a larger role remains open.
2 min

ESPN interviewed more than 30 active and retired players about brain trauma. Some accept the risks or take precautions; others leave early. Whether newer equipment reduces CTE remains unclear.
3 min

A diagnosis during life could help guide care, but players interviewed by ESPN differed over whether they would want to know—and whether a result would change their decision to keep playing.
3 min