Barred doctor supported Thomas parents’ prosecution

Peter Hindmarsh wrote an expert report after his hospital excluded him from clinical practice. Damion and Tamara Thomas, convicted following their son’s death, have applied for permission to appeal.
In this article
Peter Hindmarsh, a specialist in children’s hormones, produced an expert report supporting the prosecution of Damion and Tamara Thomas after his hospital had excluded him from clinical practice, The Guardian reported. His August 2023 report addressed whether the Birmingham couple should have sought medical help earlier for their son Joshua, who died after becoming critically ill.
University College London Hospitals had barred Hindmarsh from treating patients in March 2023 over safety concerns. A medical tribunal subsequently allowed him to continue non-clinical work, including as an expert witness. The Thomases’ jury was not told of the hospital’s exclusion or its loss of confidence in his judgment concerning insulin and diabetes.
Earlier: London hospital barred Letby trial expert from treating patients in 2023
Joshua’s death and the convictions
Joshua Thomas, 12, died on 10 December 2022, after his first episode of diabetes became critical. Postmortem examinations found severe diabetic ketoacidosis, a critical condition caused by a severe lack of insulin. Police and prosecutors argued that his parents should have recognized his symptoms and sought help earlier, particularly because Damion had diabetes.
Hindmarsh concluded that Joshua’s symptoms at 04:00 UK time on 9 December 2022, warranted a medical assessment and an earlier call for help. He did not firmly say emergency help should have been sought at 04:00.
Tamara was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect and sentenced to 3 years and 9 months in prison. Damion was acquitted of manslaughter but convicted of neglect and sentenced to 2 years and 9 months. Both maintain their innocence and have applied for permission to appeal against their convictions.
What the lawyers were told
The Guardian said the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) independently discovered in November 2025 that Hindmarsh was subject to restrictions imposed by the General Medical Council, the doctors’ regulator. After the CPS asked West Midlands Police to raise the matter with him, Hindmarsh disclosed his clinical exclusion and the regulator’s investigation.
The CPS informed the Thomases’ lawyers on 9 December 2025, after learning of the investigation, the exclusion and the tribunal’s April 2023 ruling. It decided it could continue to rely on Hindmarsh as an expert. His expert-witness self-certificate disclosed the investigation and 2 earlier tribunal rulings, but omitted the later ruling, the hospital’s concerns and his exclusion.
Alessandro Thomas, the couple’s son and representative, said the family first learned of the investigation from Guardian reporting on 3 March 2026, after Hindmarsh had testified. He called the report’s account of Hindmarsh’s clinical work misleading and said its conclusions were crucial to the case against his parents. Their trial lawyers declined to answer questions, citing client confidentiality.
Expert witnesses must tell the party instructing them about material that might reasonably undermine their opinion, credibility or impartiality, including regulatory disciplinary proceedings. Tim Green, a lawyer specializing in disclosure, said the criminal procedure rules require this as soon as reasonably practicable.
West Midlands Police said it provided information to the CPS in a timely manner as investigators received it. The CPS said it met its disclosure obligations and that the defense raised no objection to the prosecution’s expert evidence. Hindmarsh’s representative said he had no comment on the questions about the hospitals’ concerns, his exclusion, the investigation and disclosure.
The hospital’s concerns
University College London Hospitals and Great Ormond Street Hospital had reported concerns about Hindmarsh’s diagnosis and treatment of patients, including alleged harm. The regulator began an investigation in November 2022, and a tribunal ordered supervised clinical work in January 2023.
University College London Hospitals medical director Tim Hodgson later alleged that Hindmarsh had breached the supervision order and independently advised 2 child patients to stop taking insulin. Hindmarsh’s barrister disputed that he had breached the order and said no patients had been harmed.
The April tribunal said it could not determine whether the supervision conditions had technically been breached. It declined to suspend Hindmarsh, instead requiring direct supervision of clinical work while allowing non-clinical work. He was granted voluntary removal from the medical register in November 2024, ending the investigation without a final adjudication.
The Letby evidence
Hindmarsh also gave evidence in the trial of Lucy Letby, a former neonatal nurse convicted of murdering 7 babies and attempting to murder 7 others. He said tests and records showed that 2 babies had been poisoned with insulin, most likely placed in intravenous fluid bags. Prosecutors alleged Letby injected it, although there was no direct or forensic evidence that anyone had done so.
Hindmarsh told Cheshire Constabulary about the regulator’s investigation in December 2022, and the CPS informed Letby’s defense in February 2023. Her jury was not told. The defense was not informed of the later exclusion or tribunal ruling; the CPS said it had not known about either.
Letby maintains her innocence and was refused permission to appeal. Her lawyer, Mark McDonald, has asked the Criminal Cases Review Commission, which examines possible miscarriages of justice, to refer her convictions back to the Court of Appeal. Seven experts who contributed to reports submitted with his application argue that Hindmarsh’s analysis was wrong and the 2 babies were not poisoned with insulin. The commission can refer a conviction if it considers there is a real possibility that the appeal court would overturn it.
The experts dispute Hindmarsh’s calculations and diagnoses of the babies’ medical conditions, and say the evidence does not support his conclusion that insulin was placed in the fluid bags. McDonald argues that the insulin allegations shaped the jury’s view of the wider case, beyond the two related convictions.
Follow AveNews
RightsLondon hospital barred Letby trial expert from treating patients in 2023
University College London Hospitals acted over patient-safety concerns during Lucy Letby’s trial. It notified the medical regulator less than three weeks after Prof Peter Hindmarsh’s final testimony.
4 min
Sources
Guardian WorldLetby trial doctor barred from treating patients was expert witness in another case (opens in a new tab)
theguardian.comDoctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients during trial | Lucy Letby | The Guardian (opens in a new tab)
theguardian.comAfter experts find ‘no medical evidence’ of murder, will Lucy Letby get a retrial? | Lucy Letby | The Guardian (opens in a new tab)
