Lempertz keeps Koerbecke sale despite Stern claim


The Stern Foundation wants the auction paused until the claims of two victims of Nazi persecution are resolved. The paintings’ sellers are Ellen Funke’s heirs, who received them back from museums in 2025.
Cologne auction house Lempertz says it will proceed with the sale of Johann Koerbecke’s The Annunciation and The Vision of Saint Bernard after the Dr. Max and Iris Stern Foundation called for a pause.
The foundation says the sale should wait until the separate ownership claims associated with former owners Max Stern and Ellen Funke are justly resolved under the Washington Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art. Two museums returned the paintings to Funke’s heirs in December 2025; the heirs are listed as the sellers.
Funke owned the works before Stern. Nazi authorities classified her by her Jewish maternal ancestry, and she sold her collection in 1936 to finance her emigration from Germany. Stern, a German Jewish art dealer persecuted by the Nazis, held the paintings in Düsseldorf in 1936–37, before the Nazis shut his gallery in 1937.
Lempertz’s ownership history records Funke’s ownership from 1934 to 19 October 1936, followed by Galerie Stern and then Galerie Hans Bammann in Düsseldorf in 1936–37. The paintings later went separate ways: the catalogue lists Amsterdam dealer Kunsthandel P. de Boer for The Vision of Saint Bernard in 1937, before the Bavarian State Painting Collections acquired it by exchange in 1938. It lists The Annunciation at Landesmuseum Bonn on 1–5 June 1937, then in Carl Härle’s collection and inherited by Maria and Regina Härle before its donation to Cologne’s museum in 1996.

Billboard Japan named the novel its overall, literary-fiction and Reiwa-era leader in the first annual results, following the launch of its weekly book charts in November 2025.
Koerbecke was a German Gothic painter of the Westphalian School. According to Lempertz’s catalogue, the Bavarian State Painting Collections returned The Vision of Saint Bernard and Kolumba returned The Annunciation to Funke’s heirs in December 2025.
The paintings were originally opposite sides of one panel. Lempertz’s catalogue says the panel was separated at Stern’s instigation in 1936 against the owner’s wishes. Lempertz’s catalog says they probably belonged to a smaller altarpiece at Marienfeld monastery, probably completed around 1470–80, rather than the monastery’s better-known high altarpiece completed in 1457.
Lempertz told ARTnews that it follows federal restitution recommendations. Its catalog says the museums examined the works and returned them to the primary affected parties under those guidelines. The Stern Foundation acknowledges that the museums applied Germany’s priority principle but says the returns did not achieve a just and fair solution for both claims.
Lempertz says the paintings were not taken from Stern, that he had the panel sawn apart and sold one resulting painting for double the price, and that he received compensation after the war while Funke’s heirs did not. The foundation disputes the auction house’s account of Stern’s loss and says he was not compensated for these paintings and that the assertion has no legal basis. It cites a 2019 German Advisory Commission statement that ordinary business transactions could not be assumed after persecution of Jewish dealers began no later than August 1933.
The Washington Principles are nonbinding guidelines that call for just and fair solutions suited to each case. A 2018 German–US declaration says earlier compensation does not bar restitution and calls on auction houses to follow the principles, which it says apply to private as well as public collections.
The foundation says both paintings have appeared in Interpol’s stolen-art database since 2021; it registered a claim for both with Germany’s Lost Art database in 2018, where both are listed as Nazi-confiscated property. Lempertz does not dispute their listing on the Art Loss Register and says those entries also record the museums’ restitutions.
The Old Masters sale is planned for Saturday. The Annunciation is lot 1005 and The Vision of Saint Bernard is lot 1006; each has a high estimate of around €300,000. Lempertz says it will offer the paintings individually and then together for art-historical reasons.
3 min

Armenia’s culture ministry said a government funeral commission will be formed for the People’s Artist, with his wake and final farewell to take place in Vanadzor.
1 min

Rockstar Games’ title joins 007 First Light, Control Resonant, Phantom Blade Zero, Resident Evil Requiem and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time in the Game of the Year field.
4 min