Lyft defends driver classification as law professor criticizes $272.5 million settlement

The proposed deal concerns 2016–2020 claims and still needs court approval. Lyft disputes misclassification; UC Irvine’s Veena Dubal says drivers are owed more.

The proposed deal concerns 2016–2020 claims and still needs court approval. Lyft disputes misclassification; UC Irvine’s Veena Dubal says drivers are owed more.
In a statement to Ars Technica, Lyft CEO David Risher said the company believes its California drivers have always been properly classified under the law. Veena Dubal, a law professor at the University of California, Irvine and a longtime critic of Uber and Lyft, told the outlet that the proposed settlement is a “paltry sum” compared with what she says drivers are owed.
Lyft has agreed to a proposed $272.5 million settlement in a California lawsuit alleging that it wrongly treated drivers as independent contractors rather than employees. Payment requires court approval, Engadget reported on October 2, citing an announcement by California Attorney General Rob Bonta.
If approved, at least $237.075 million of the total would be reserved to compensate workers for unpaid minimum wages and benefits. The attorney general’s statement says driver eligibility and compensation would be based on hours and miles driven from April 5, 2016, through December 15, 2020.
California filed the lawsuit against Lyft and Uber in May 2020, after the passage of Assembly Bill 5 in 2019. That law put the “ABC test” into statute: criteria businesses must use to show that workers are independent contractors rather than employees. Under the law’s original wording, Lyft and Uber drivers could be classified as employees entitled to minimum wages and other protections.
Both companies backed Proposition 22, a ballot measure passed in November 2020. It created exceptions to the ABC test that classified gig workers as contractors while guaranteeing certain benefits, including healthcare subsidies. Workers challenged the measure, but the California Supreme Court upheld it in 2024. The settlement concerns historical claims, separate from the contractor classification established by Proposition 22.
Individual payouts and a payment timetable are not yet known. If the court approves the settlement, it would resolve California’s claims against Lyft; the case against Uber continues.

Most survey vessels cannot operate in the shallows, leaving inland captains to judge whether passage is safe.
1 min

Proposed sales of 15 convenience stores and two funeral homes could resolve concerns over the Southern Co-op takeover, but the regulator’s assessment remains provisional.
2 min

Record renewable electricity generation reduced the need to burn gas, but the estimated import value is not a measure of household bill savings.
3 min