Why a higgsino might explain LZ’s dark-matter hint—and where it struggles

A hypothetical particle with two mass states could explain the unusual signal. Missing neutrinos and a disputed reading of higher-energy data complicate that explanation.

A hypothetical particle with two mass states could explain the unusual signal. Missing neutrinos and a disputed reading of higher-energy data complicate that explanation.
A single high-energy event in the LUX-ZEPLIN detector has prompted physicists to reconsider a hypothetical dark-matter particle called the higgsino. The particle could explain why the detector saw no accompanying lower-energy events, but other observations make that explanation difficult. As Science News reported on October 5, the signal announced by the LZ collaboration on September 1 could still come from known physics. It establishes neither dark matter nor supersymmetry.
Dark matter is unidentified matter whose presence is inferred from its gravitational effects on galaxies and other cosmic objects. LZ searches for its particles using a large tank of liquid xenon at the Sanford Underground Research Facility in Lead, South Dakota. A passing particle could strike a xenon atomic nucleus, causing the nucleus to recoil—to move away from the collision.
The nucleus in LZ’s event recoiled with particularly high energy. Most dark-matter candidates would also produce lower-energy recoils, but LZ did not see those. That combination is what makes a higgsino worth considering.
A higgsino belongs to supersymmetry, a theory proposing that each known particle has a heavier counterpart called a superpartner. The higgsino would be the superpartner of the Higgs boson, the particle discovered in 2012 that explains the origin of mass. Such a superpartner could constitute dark matter. Particle colliders have not found evidence for supersymmetry, so identifying a higgsino would have significance beyond explaining this one event.
In the explanation described by Science News, the higgsino has two mass states: a lighter state and a heavier one. A collision can happen only if enough energy is available to move the particle from the lighter state to the heavier state. This minimum energy requirement would prevent lower-energy nuclear recoils, potentially explaining their absence in LZ.
Analysis
The first challenge comes from the sun. Higgsinos could interact there and become trapped by its gravity. Under the supersymmetry explanation, trapped higgsinos would annihilate one another and produce high-energy particles called neutrinos. In a September 2 paper posted on arXiv, theoretical physicist Harikrishnan Ramani and a colleague argued that IceCube, the neutrino detector at the South Pole, should have observed those neutrinos. That predicted signal has not been seen.
The second challenge concerns still higher energies in LZ itself. In a September 3 paper, theoretical physicist Tracy Slatyer and colleagues examined a plot in an appendix to LZ’s paper. They argued that, if the reported event came from a higgsino, more events should appear at those higher energies. LZ had not reported anything resembling dark matter there.
That interpretation has an important limit: LZ spokesperson Rick Gaitskell said the detector was not calibrated for that energy range, meaning its response there had not been established for interpreting the measurements. The collaboration therefore did not treat the region as a formal test of whether dark matter was present.
We didn’t make any formal claims about detection or even nondetection in that event region
The missing solar-neutrino signal is thus a separate challenge from the higher-energy plot. The plot would make the higgsino explanation harder to sustain if interpreted as Slatyer’s team proposes, but LZ has not established a nondetection in that region.
Analysis
Changing the assumed higgsino mass could improve the fit to LZ, Science News reports. But the usual mass is chosen to account for the amount of dark matter in the universe today. Moving away from it complicates that explanation.
| Proposal | Mass | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Usual theoretical expectation | About 1,000 times a proton’s mass | Account for the observed amount of cosmic dark matter. |
| Freese and a coauthor’s October 2 proposal | Around 2,000 times a proton’s mass | Provide a possible explanation for LZ’s event. |
Another possibility is that dark-matter particles in the Milky Way reach higher speeds than usually assumed. For a faster higgsino to produce LZ’s event, the explanation would require a larger gap between its two mass states. That larger energy requirement would leave higgsinos fewer opportunities to produce neutrinos in the sun, potentially accommodating the missing IceCube signal.
Theoretical physicist Katherine Freese and a coauthor explored these adjustments in an October 2 arXiv preprint, a research paper posted before peer-reviewed publication. Science News reports their conclusion that the higgsino explanation could still work. The proposed mass and speeds are theoretical possibilities, not measured properties or verified findings.
A particle with similar two-state behavior need not be a higgsino. Theoretical physicist Dan Hooper and colleagues have considered other particles that would not face all the requirements imposed by supersymmetry. For example, particles trapped in the sun would not necessarily produce neutrinos, so IceCube’s missing signal would not rule them out.
Scientists are awaiting further LZ results to see whether similar events appear. XENONnT, another dark-matter experiment at Italy’s Gran Sasso National Laboratory, is examining its existing data for high-energy events. These cross-checks could help determine whether LZ’s isolated signal has a counterpart in another detector.

The September 25 recall covers four 28oz varieties across 37 US states and concerns people who may be sensitive to Yellow No 5 or Yellow No 6.
1 min

Altman puts spending on OpenAI’s claimed Navier–Stokes solution at around $10 million, “maybe a little more,” and says the company holds further unpublished mathematical discoveries.
2 min

The physicists will split $100,000. NIST links Ye’s award to control of ultracold atoms that enabled advances in precision clocks.
2 min