Manchester City may play in Europe despite domestic sanctions, BBC says


Cup wins could give City a European place next season even if it is relegated. BBC Sport says licensing rules use current information, not historical offences.
Manchester City would not automatically be excluded from a European competition it qualifies for through its results, even if a domestic punishment relegates the club, BBC Sport reported on 7 October 2026. Senior figures in English football are concerned that City could still play in next season's Champions League and receive its financial rewards after a severe domestic sanction. That concern is not a decision about City's punishment or European eligibility.
According to BBC Sport, winning the Champions League would qualify City for the following season's competition as defending champion, regardless of which division it plays in in England. A points deduction could prevent qualification through its league position without closing cup routes. Winning the FA Cup would provide a Europa League place, while winning the Carabao Cup, England's league cup, would provide a Conference League place.
Clubs also need a licence to play in competitions run by UEFA, European football's governing body. BBC Sport reports that England's Football Association issues these licences, with the process delegated to the Premier League. The licences use current information and do not take account of sanctions or breaches relating to historical offences. A licence cannot be refused if a club meets all minimum admission criteria. The main financial reasons for refusal concern overdue payments to clubs or players, or outstanding tax liabilities—not punishment for past breaches.
Liverpool is assessing compensation options following the ruling against Manchester City, ESPN reported on 6 October 2026, drawing on sources at the club. In a separate report on 2 October, the Guardian said earlier funding statements by City's sponsor Etihad Airways appeared to contradict a reported argument in City's appeal.

Before kickoff in Seville, Spain's captain showed the World Cup trophy to fans. The teenage Yamal then scored two goals and set up a third, just after voting for the Ballon d'Or had closed.
The Premier League confirmed on 29 September that City had been found guilty of financial-rule breaches covering the 2009-10 to 2017-18 seasons. City continues to deny wrongdoing. The independent commission that heard the case did not include compensation for other parties within its judgment, so rival clubs would have to pursue claims separately from City's disciplinary punishment.
According to ESPN, Arsenal, Liverpool, Manchester United and Tottenham instructed lawyers in September 2024 to notify City that they reserved their right to seek compensation if it was found guilty. This preserved their options amid concerns about a six-year limitation period—a time limit for bringing a claim—running from Der Spiegel's initial publication of the allegations. Reserving those rights was not the same as filing a lawsuit.
Possible claims concern revenue from qualifying for the Champions League, Europe's leading club competition, and Premier League merit payments, which depend on finishing position. ESPN's estimates for United and Tottenham describe potential compensation arguments, not damages established by the commission.
| Club | Qualification record | Potential revenue argument and limits |
|---|---|---|
| Manchester United | Finished fifth in 2015-16, behind fourth-placed City on goal difference, missing the final Champions League place. | Around £25 million in potential Champions League prize money. ESPN said this would have been partly offset by £5.5 million from winning the 2016-17 Europa League and receipts of £3 million per home game across seven games. |
| Tottenham | Finished fifth with City above them in four of the five seasons following May 2010. | ESPN suggested Tottenham could argue for at least £120 million in lost Champions League revenue, before Premier League merit payments. This is a potential claim estimate, not an award. |
ESPN also suggested United could argue that its diminished standing affected commercial revenue and required higher wages to attract players, but cautioned that both arguments would be difficult to prove. Arsenal and Tottenham declined to comment to ESPN, and whether either club will pursue compensation remains unclear.
City submitted its appeal on 1 October and confirmed it the following day, the Guardian reported on 2 October. The club said it had "a body of irrefutable evidence" that would prove the commission's findings untrue.
The Guardian reported that a key part of the appeal was understood to be City's argument that commercial contracts the commission found were partly funded by its owner had actually been paid for by the Abu Dhabi government. The question is who supplied the money recorded as sponsorship income. The commission rejected that explanation as "untrue" and said City had devised it after the event to conceal the funding arrangement.
The Guardian compared that reported defence with Etihad's 2015 submission to the US departments of Commerce, Transportation and State during an investigation into state-owned airlines. Etihad called the assertion that the Abu Dhabi government paid for its City sponsorship "false". It said its 2011 agreement ran for ten years and included naming rights for City's stadium.
Etihad funded this sponsorship from its own liquidity.
Liquidity means readily available funds. Etihad acknowledged in the submission that it was government-owned, but said it received no government subsidies and was financed through equity, shareholder loans and commercial loans. It distinguished its government shareholder's investments and loans from subsidies. The state-owned United Arab Emirates airline has been City's principal shirt sponsor since 2009. City announced the £400 million stadium naming-rights agreement in 2011 and extended it on improved terms in 2021.
The Guardian also described the reported argument as a departure from City's position in its successful 2020 appeal against Uefa's financial fair play charges at the Court of Arbitration for Sport. In that case, City maintained that all sponsorship income came from its commercial partners. The comparison with Etihad's statements does not resolve the current appeal; City continues to reject the findings against it.
BBC Sport reported on 30 September that City's breaches included artificially inflating revenue by more than £900 million through "sham" sponsorship deals. A separate BBC analysis that day described £830 million in owner funding disguised as sponsorship income. The commission characterised the accounting misconduct as a "concerted campaign to falsify" City's accounts.
The BBC analysis said City spent about £1.2 billion on new players between summer 2009 and January 2018, including Sergio Aguero, Kevin de Bruyne, David Silva and Yaya Toure. Sponsorship was not City's only income source, and income also paid wages and other costs, not just transfers. BBC Sport reported eight trophies during the period; the transfer analysis counted seven major trophies—three Premier League titles, one FA Cup and three EFL Cups—and said City had previously gone without a significant honour since 1970.
As BBC Sport reported on 29 September, the Premier League charged City in February 2023 after a four-year investigation and referred the case to an independent commission. A private hearing began in September 2024 and lasted about 12 weeks.
Etihad's possible legal action concerns a different issue and opponent. BBC Sport reported on 30 September that the airline was considering action against the Premier League over its public communication of the findings. Etihad categorically rejected any finding, conclusion or implication that it had been involved in improper commercial arrangements and said it would seek legal advice about its options.
Etihad said the communication had created damaging implications for the airline after what it called "selective leaks and reporting". It said it was not named in the published, redacted findings, which withheld some details, and had been given no opportunity to take part in the process. Its statement did not announce a filed lawsuit or overturn the findings against City. BBC Sport said it had contacted the Premier League for a response.
The Football Association, England's football governing body, said it was considering the decision and would "take action where appropriate", the Guardian reported on 2 October. The FA has powers to discipline City and individuals at the club, but will wait until the appeal process concludes before deciding whether to act.
The FA said the ruling had "significant implications for the integrity of the game" and that it would continue monitoring developments while league proceedings remained ongoing. The names of individuals involved were withheld in the commission's published 40-page core judgment; the Guardian reported that the FA could request an unredacted version from the Premier League.
City's punishment and appeal outcome remain unresolved. BBC Sport reported on 7 October that the hearing to determine City's punishment had not yet been scheduled. The independent commission decides the punishment, with City and the Premier League board able to propose a suitable sanction before the panel's decision.
Removing titles was among the possible punishments BBC Sport described on 29 September. It reported that City had won eight Premier League titles since Sheikh Mansour's takeover, three during the period covered by the charges. The guilty verdict itself did not reallocate those honours.
BBC Sport's 30 September report said one section of Premier League regulations says an appeal should conclude within 12 weeks of filing, with a decision within 30 days of its conclusion. The Guardian's 2 October report put the expected end of the appeal process at the end of January, based on the rule book.
BBC Sport reported on 7 October that it was unconfirmed whether the Premier League's new disciplinary timeframes applied to City's case; completion of the whole process, including an appeal against the sanction, by season's end was not guaranteed. UEFA cannot act while the Premier League disciplinary process continues, but may open a separate disciplinary case seeking to remove City's European eligibility. That possible route is uncertain because the offences are historical: in 2020, the Court of Arbitration for Sport overturned City's two-year European ban because the offences were time-barred under UEFA rules. This is a possible proceeding, not an announced case or exclusion decision.
Anonymous senior football figures told BBC Sport they wanted the case resolved by the end of the season, and one hoped the appeal could be shortened. Those expectations were not an agreed deadline. City's chief executive, Ferran Soriano, had suggested the case would run for a long time.
Sources had already told BBC Sport on 29 September that other Premier League clubs were seeking legal advice about compensation. ESPN's 6 October report expected clubs to wait until City's sanction was confirmed before deciding whether and how to pursue claims. That is a reported expectation, not an announced decision by the clubs; reserving legal rights leaves them options but does not establish damages.
2 min

Trent Alexander-Arnold crossed for Anthony Gordon's opener in Prague on his first start under Thomas Tuchel, helping England secure their first win in Nations League Group A3.
3 min