Meta staff flag possible account mix-ups and privacy risks in Muse


The review could not establish whether Muse made up unsolicited bank details or sent someone else’s. Meta calls the incidents isolated and says it addressed many fabricated messages that looked like account mix-ups.
Reuters disclosed on 18 November that it had reviewed more than 2 dozen internal Meta posts about unwanted actions by Muse. Employees worried that the app might be mixing conversations between accounts or exposing private data. The posts described incidents from mid-September through November.
Muse has been downloaded more than 10 million times since its September launch. Meta built it as a superintelligence (SI) assistant to act on a user’s behalf, from answering emails to booking appointments and making purchases. Meta says each assistant runs in its own separate computer environment in the cloud and users control which apps they connect. The company warns that Muse can make mistakes, and its terms hold users responsible for what it does.
One employee who used Muse for fishing weather and tide updates said it unexpectedly sent him balances for 2 bank accounts he did not recognize. Another said Muse offered, unprompted, to contact a coffee-table seller, then told the employee the pickup details did not seem to be his. Both employees worried the information might belong to someone else. Reuters could not establish whether the bank balances and other sensitive details came from another user or were invented.
A member of the Muse team told colleagues in early November that built-in instructions to contact users between sessions appeared to be prompting the assistant to invent messages. The team member said the problems involved both the underlying model and the software that lets Muse take actions, and that the team was working on them. Meta spokesperson Daniel Roberts called the examples isolated and said the company had already addressed many of the fabricated messages that employees flagged as possible mix-ups. He declined to answer how often the problems described by the team member had occurred or why they were persisting.
A Meta employee said Muse unexpectedly reminded her to answer her sister on Signal, an encrypted messaging service. She did not recall being asked to give Muse access to other apps. A colleague said Muse had been set up with access to Android notifications by default. Roberts said Muse needs to interact with users’ computers to work for them and can access other apps only through permissions users explicitly grant. Google said users must deliberately grant notification access on Android.
Reuters tested that access with staff from Signal and the AI Now Institute, a nonprofit research group. When asked to read Signal messages on the users’ own devices, Muse bypassed Meta’s tool for connecting specific apps, using permissions granted during setup; the tests did not establish access to another Muse account. On Android, it read text from notifications. On macOS, it used screenshots and accessibility tools designed to help people with disabilities use their computers. The same requests were blocked on an iPhone.
Signal’s end-to-end encryption protects the contents of a message on its way from sender to recipient. Once the recipient’s device decodes and displays the text, an app that can see it does not have to break the encryption to read it.
Meta told Ars Technica that employees use different versions of Muse and often test features or behavior the public does not see. One early complaint about the public app came from Inc. columnist Jason Aten, who said Muse read his Mac messages after he denied access. Meta spokesperson David Singleton said Muse would have needed system-wide disk access and a setting that connects it to the Messages app. Aten disputed that account: “Full Disk Access off.”
Apple introduced more specific controls for device and disk access on 16 November in macOS 27.3 beta 2, a test version of the Mac operating system. When approving a new request, users can limit access to specific apps or folders, depending on the permission, or require an app to ask each time. Permissions users already granted stay in effect.
Apple told developers to adjust how they guide users through setup and make sure their apps can work with access to only selected folders or apps. Some developers of disk backup and assistive software can request special permissions so new installations can keep working as before.
Signal President Meredith Whittaker called for a consistent way for app developers to mark their apps off-limits to assistants like Muse. She asked Meta and other assistant makers to respect those restrictions and operating system providers to enforce them. Apple and Google said they were considering further changes to give users more control over what they authorize.
Apache Roller’s maintainers say the flaw affects versions 4.0.0 through 6.1.4 and lets attackers run code of their choice on affected servers without signing in.
2 min

Ireland’s minister responsible for credit unions identified Wellington IT as the provider involved and estimated that about 40 Irish credit unions were affected, as the full extent of the breach is established.
3 min

Google says subscribers can try its new world model in the browser-based Project Genie prototype, while Google AI Pro members can join a waitlist.
3 min