US National Academies pauses research integrity report


The nonprofit says citations need further review after Science alleged that 10 references contained apparently fabricated co-author first names.
The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine paused publication of a report on correcting and retracting scientific research on 19 November, after Science identified apparent problems in its references.
Jennifer Walsh, a spokesperson for the US nonprofit, told STAT that some citations needed further review. Science alleged that 10 references contained apparently fabricated first names for co-authors and suggested a large language model might have written the references; that possibility has not been established.
The report addresses a problem in the published scientific record: unreliable findings can remain available for years. Retraction Watch data show that retractions occur an average of 2.4 years after publication. A retraction marks an already published paper as unreliable; the Academies instead paused its own report before publication.
The committee was asked to review practices for correcting scientific literature and propose clearer standards to improve the timeliness, transparency and consistency of corrections. It was chaired by Randy Schekman, a University of California, Berkeley cell biologist, and included Holden Thorp, editor-in-chief of the Science family of journals.
For concerns about a single paper, the report recommends completing editorial reviews within 12 weeks in most cases and rarely taking more than 6 months. Its proposed sequence is:
The report also urges journals to look for errors rather than wait for complaints and to disclose when they were alerted to a problem. Journals generally do not disclose that date, so there are no data on how long corrections or retractions take after an alert. Existing Committee on Publication Ethics guidelines call for a timely response but set no expected schedule.
The panel also urges researchers to keep original data, institutions to respond faster to integrity inquiries and share their findings, and funders to tie grants to research-conduct and error-correction standards. It warns that uncorrected findings can affect policy and public health decisions and lead researchers to waste time and public money pursuing faulty results.
Lisa Rasmussen, a bioethicist at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte and editor-in-chief of Accountability in Research, said editors are stretched thin and often poorly compensated. She said submissions to her journal had increased almost tenfold over five years, making the proposed timetable harder to meet as concerns and queries rise.
Rasmussen also said the report gave surprisingly little attention to superintelligence (SI), which she said is used to review and critique research as well as fabricate data.
Advance copies went to media outlets, but the report had not appeared on the Academies’ website by the evening of 19 November. The Academies postponed its release webinar, and Walsh had not provided a new publication time.
A separate agreement covers up to 8.78 million tonnes of emissions reductions in Morocco. Norway will pay only after the cuts are achieved, independently verified and transferred.
3 min

The launch company says flight engines are shipping weekly for integration with Nova’s first stage as they pass acceptance tests. The rocket’s upper stage is still being tested.
2 min

Oil from attacked tankers is washing onto beaches in the United Arab Emirates and threatening dive sites in Oman, as a map tracks slicks across the region.
2 min