
The order follows September’s consumer-protection verdict. New Mexico’s attorney general says state law directs all the penalty money to schools.
New Mexico Judge Francis Mathew ordered Meta to pay $25 billion on 21 October after a jury found on 25 September that the company misled consumers about privacy and other platform practices. Reuters reported on 23 October that the state’s outside lawyers could receive up to $1.27 billion from that recovery under their contract, if the full judgment survives appeal and the court approves maximum fees.
New Mexico hired Chicago-based law firm DiCello Levitt to represent it. Reuters obtained the state’s 2025 contract through a records request. It allows the firm to ask the judge for a share of any eventual recovery, with lower percentages applying to successive portions of the total.
| Portion of the recovery | Maximum contractual fee |
|---|---|
| First $50 million | 20% |
| Next $50 million | 15% |
| Next $150 million | 10% |
| Amounts above $250 million | 5% |
Applied to a $25 billion recovery, that schedule would allow fees of up to $1.27 billion. This is a conditional contractual maximum, not a fee award. The judge need not approve the maximum, and Meta could overturn the judgment or secure a reduction on appeal.
The fees would come out of the money Meta pays New Mexico, rather than being an extra payment on top. Attorney General previously said state law directs all the penalty money to New Mexico’s school system. A fee award under the contract would therefore reduce the funds left from the recovery.
The contract also lets DiCello Levitt appoint other lawyers as subcontractors. Randi McGinn, who delivered New Mexico’s opening statement and closing argument, told Reuters that her small Albuquerque firm is entitled to about 33% of DiCello Levitt’s fees. That share would come from the firm’s fees, not represent a separate percentage of the state’s recovery. DiCello Levitt declined to comment about its fees.
These arrangements are known as contingency fees: outside lawyers typically receive a share of winnings rather than charge by the hour. Reuters reported that states increasingly use private firms to strengthen their legal teams against large technology companies. Some companies and business groups argue that this gives lawyers financial interests that can conflict with public policy; defenders say it helps states match companies’ legal resources.
New Mexico filed the lawsuit in 2021, accusing Meta of misleading users about data privacy, as Engadget reported on 2 October. The case followed disclosures that Cambridge Analytica, a now-defunct British political consulting firm, obtained Facebook users’ information without consent for voter profiling and political advertising. Reuters’ 23 October account put the number at as many as 87 million users.
Jurors found that Meta violated New Mexico’s Unfair Practices Act, its consumer-protection law, by misleading residents about privacy and its handling of misinformation. They found 26 of 29 statements misleading and counted more than 43 million violations, based on the Facebook users or New Mexico residents who were the audience for each statement. That count provided the basis for a penalty, not a dollar award itself.
According to Ars Technica’s 22 October account, Mathew found that senior leaders, including Mark Zuckerberg, knew Facebook was making misleading public statements. He said this supported the highest statutory penalty. The judge cited internal messages showing that Zuckerberg used users’ limited understanding to encourage more public sharing. One message said: “Give them a chance to change their privacy settings but obviously don’t encourage it.”
Mathew said Facebook notified users about only two of 2,000 distinct apps associated with data misuse. He found that the company deliberately narrowed its definition of misuse to notify fewer people because of the operational burden. He also found that promises of equal treatment conflicted with practices giving some celebrities and influencers warnings before violations were recorded and reversals of content decisions that ordinary users would not obtain.
Meta had pointed to its $5 billion Federal Trade Commission settlement over Cambridge Analytica. Mathew said earlier penalties, consent agreements and court orders had not deterred deceptive practices. He described the wrongdoing as systematic, extending over years and reaching the heart of Facebook’s business.
State law allows up to $5,000 per violation. Mathew found that a penalty exceeding $219 billion was warranted under that law, but reduced it to $25 billion.
| Request or decision | Amount |
|---|---|
| New Mexico’s requested penalty | $35 billion–$40 billion |
| Meta’s proposed cap | $3.45 billion |
| Judge’s ordered penalty | $25 billion |
At the 1 October hearing, McGinn argued that the state’s request followed the verdict and constitutional due-process protections requiring fair legal proceedings. She said the penalty needed to be large enough to affect Meta. Meta argued that a higher penalty could drive businesses out of New Mexico, that it did not sell user data and that the state had not proved any consumer was actually misled.
Meta denies wrongdoing and plans to appeal. It had argued that a penalty above its proposed cap would be unconstitutional. Responding to the order, a spokesperson said the ruling and the attorney general’s enforcement approach made doing business in New Mexico all but impossible.
Legal experts consulted by Reuters said Meta had a strong basis to argue for a reduction. The eventual recovery, and any fees approved from it, depend on the outcome of the planned appeal. McGinn cautioned that a final outcome could take several years.

The order follows a jury finding that Meta misled residents about data sharing and enforcement of hate-speech and misinformation policies, CNA reports.
1 min

The order follows a September jury finding over Facebook’s privacy and moderation policies and creates a liability separate from Meta’s August multistate settlement.
2 min