New York City requires cancellation through signup channels

The rule took effect on October 1, 2026. Covered subscription businesses face city penalties and liability for charges after a consumer’s first attempt to cancel.

The rule took effect on October 1, 2026. Covered subscription businesses face city penalties and liability for charges after a consumer’s first attempt to cancel.
New York City’s “Click to Cancel” rule took effect on October 1, 2026. Covered subscription businesses must make cancellation as easy to use as signup and offer it through every channel they use to accept subscriptions, according to the rule text cited by Music Business Worldwide.
New York State already has an automatic-renewal law, General Business Law § 527-a, whose notification requirements the city rule largely mirrors. The city’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) identifies three additions: its own civil penalties, a defined measure of restitution—the money violators must repay consumers—and a wider set of required cancellation channels.
A service that accepts subscriptions through a website, app and phone must allow cancellation through all three—not just the channel a particular customer used. When a customer subscribes in person, the business must additionally provide an online cancellation route, such as a website or email.
The rule requires a clear, conspicuous and streamlined cancellation method. It also limits discounts or other offers intended to persuade customers to stay: once cancellation begins, an offer cannot obstruct or unreasonably delay it. DCWP clarified when adopting the rule that these offers are not banned outright and that the restriction is intended to match the equivalent state provision.
Failing to provide the required cancellation method is classified as a deceptive and unconscionable trade practice under the city’s Consumer Protection Law. Music Business Worldwide reports the following civil penalties:
| Violation | Penalty (USD) |
|---|---|
| First | $525 |
| Second | $1,050 |
| Third and subsequent | $3,500 |
Violators are also liable for money charged to a consumer after that consumer’s first attempt to cancel, under section 5-110.2. The repayment provision therefore reaches charges made after an attempted cancellation, not only after a business completes it.
The rule also sets notice deadlines for changes to subscription terms, certain long-term renewals and free trials. Notices of material changes, including price increases, must be clear and conspicuous, according to the text cited by Music Business Worldwide.
| Trigger | Notice window |
|---|---|
| A material change to terms, including a price increase | At least five business days, but no more than 30 days, before the change |
| An initial paid term of at least one year that renews for at least six months | 15–45 days before the cancellation deadline |
| A free trial lasting longer than one month | 3–21 days before the cancellation deadline for the first chargeable period |
The rule applies to covered businesses offering automatic renewals or continuous services—subscriptions that renew or keep running without a new signup. These include music and video streaming services, telecommunications providers, gyms and publishers selling subscriptions in New York City.
Music Business Worldwide lists these exemptions:
Music and video streaming services are not exempted categories. Industry groups opposed the proposal, arguing that existing state law was sufficient and that a local rule could cause confusion. DCWP rejected that argument and a separate request for a telecommunications exemption based on federal consumer protections.
This is a New York City rule, not a nationwide requirement. The US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit vacated the Federal Trade Commission’s separate click-to-cancel rule on July 8, 2025, before it was due to take effect.
Consumers who believe a business has breached the city rule can file a complaint with DCWP. The department may assign a mediator to seek a settlement between the consumer and the business.

September’s ISM activity index stayed above the expansion threshold, while its measure of prices paid by businesses increased.
2 min

The reported agreement covers financing over four years, but eligibility, pricing and rollout timing remain unclear.

The deal would transfer production, bottling and sales responsibilities to Carlsberg, but still needs approval from Armenia’s competition regulator.
2 min
1 min