NHS Grampian review finds 19 surgical deaths avoidable


Surgeon Mohammed Habib has called for a corporate homicide investigation after disclosing a 2022 review of care at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary; the health board had yet to comment on his latest allegations.
A previously unpublished 2022 expert review found that 19 deaths were avoidable consequences of surgery or intervention among 45 patients treated by Aberdeen Royal Infirmary’s liver and pancreatic surgery service between 2015 and 2021. The reviewers said 31 of the patients had died.
Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant surgeon at the hospital, disclosed the review and called for a corporate homicide investigation into NHS Grampian, alleging recklessness and indifference to patient deaths. The health board’s management had not commented on his latest allegations when the BBC published its account.
The disclosure follows a separate November 2026 review by Healthcare Improvement Scotland that found major deficiencies in the board’s examination of a death during surgery, as well as wider weaknesses in leadership and oversight.
Earlier: Scotland’s watchdog finds leadership failures across NHS Grampian
The 2022 reviewers said surgical mistakes caused some patients to bleed to death in the operating theater. They criticized high blood loss, decision-making and a lack of leadership and clear standards for planning operations. They said some liver operations went ahead when the disease was thought to be inoperable, while pancreatic patients were regularly rushed into surgery without adequate planning or consideration of alternatives.

The review found an inadequate investigation into a surgical death and misleading information from the health board’s chief executive. Health Secretary Angela Constance has promised Parliament an update on further action next week.
Separately from the reviewed cases, the experts examined deaths after major liver resections, operations that remove part of the liver, in 2017–2020. They cited an expected death rate of 2.2%.
| Time after surgery | Death rate |
|---|---|
| 30 days | 12% |
| 90 days | 18% |
A separate external surgical review in 2026 found longstanding, recurring problems, too few specialist staff and a lack of necessary structural changes. It strongly recommended that complex or major liver, pancreas and bile duct surgery no longer take place at the hospital.
Habib said he had tried to raise concerns through whistleblowing procedures. His account spans several years:
Habib said he had repeatedly contacted Scotland’s first minister and health secretary since June 2023, but the Scottish Government said it had no jurisdiction to investigate whistleblowing claims. He also said the Independent National Whistleblowing Officer refused to progress his complaints.
In response to his correspondence in December 2025, NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight asked Habib to let Healthcare Improvement Scotland complete its inquiries and said she had nothing further to add at that stage.
Under Scots law, corporate homicide requires an organization’s management or organization of its activities to have caused a death and amounted to a gross breach of a relevant duty of care. Senior management’s role must be a substantial element of that breach.
Scotland’s Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service assesses police reports and decides whether to prosecute. Procurators fiscal can direct police investigations in complex cases.
Skaife-Knight commissioned the separate diagnostic review amid persistent concerns about safety and leadership. It found that the board’s examination of a surgical death did not adequately analyze key contributing factors and lacked sufficient senior oversight. Healthcare Improvement Scotland also found that the board provided it with incorrect information and inconsistent accounts of executive medical involvement; the watchdog said it had not received a satisfactory explanation. In response to that review, Skaife-Knight said the board accepted its findings and apologized to patients, families and communities.
On 17 November, Scotland’s Health Secretary Angela Constance announced strengthened stage 4 oversight and an external intervention support team. She said the board and chief executive remained accountable. Constance said she would reassess the situation in six weeks and could move to stage 5, the highest level, which entails direct intervention when organizational problems are sufficiently serious.
Healthcare Improvement Scotland will be asked to review progress within three months, with further reviews to be published. NHS Grampian plans to set out immediate improvement priorities at a public board meeting on 3 December, followed by a more detailed update on 21 January 2027.
People with specific concerns who want to speak to the health board can call its dedicated line on 08085 202030.
2 min