US health agency renegotiates over 5,000 grants, HIV study drops cash


Researcher Jade Pagkas-Bather says funding conditions led her to remove cash payments from her $1.3 million Chicago HIV study; she plans to use vouchers and seek renewed consent from participants.
The National Institutes of Health (NIH) told The Guardian that it has renegotiated more than 5,000 new and continuing grants. One researcher, Jade Pagkas-Bather, said funding conditions led her to remove cash payments from her HIV study after she was told she would otherwise need to find $1 million elsewhere.
The process began in 2025, after court battles slowed the Trump administration’s grant cancellations. NIH then developed a process to bring grants into alignment with administration priorities.
Pagkas-Bather’s original trial was designed to test whether $500 monthly cash payments helped low-income young people living with HIV in Chicago stay on treatment. The randomized trial would assign participants to groups for comparison; dozens enrolled.
She said that after scientific peer review in summer 2025, NIH officers asked her to remove references to gender identities and racial differences in poverty. She made the changes and received funding. In 2026, she said she was told to remove unconditional cash transfers and references to the study’s potential policy impact.
Pagkas-Bather plans to use food and transportation vouchers instead and must ask participants to consent again because the study has changed.
A comparison by Grant Witness, an independent group that tracks canceled government grants, counted changes in grant titles, abstracts or public-health statements. Those text changes do not establish how many studies were substantively redesigned.

The institute conducting the excavation also found a finely dressed stone furnace at the edge of the site, where archaeologists think bathhouses may once have stood.
| Year | All renewal or continuation grants changed | HIV-related continuation grants changed |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 154 of more than 40,000 (0.4%) | — |
| 2025 | more than 3,401 of more than 39,000 (8.6%) | 305 of 1,795 (17%) |
| 2026 | 3,006 of nearly 35,500 (8.5%) | 335 of 1,609 (20.8%) |
NIH said renegotiations aim to fund meritorious science, address urgent health needs and sustain the biomedical research workforce. It said research scopes were substantively altered wherever possible to replace concepts it considered poorly defined, nonscientific or subjective with scientific concepts using objective, measurable variables.
The Guardian said the process uses a text-analysis tool to flag grants for alignment review. NIH said renegotiation is a longstanding practice and that human experts assess all renegotiated grants. Director Jay Bhattacharya has repeatedly denied that a banned-word list exists.
Pagkas-Bather is one of 14 named plaintiffs alleging that grant cancellations and renegotiations amount to unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination. The case, Salles et al. v. National Institutes of Health et al., was filed in the US District Court for the Northern District of California under the First Amendment and the Administrative Procedure Act.
The American Civil Liberties Union, which is involved in the case, says the plaintiffs seek relief for researchers whose grants were terminated under the challenged policies and not reinstated, as well as those facing further terminations, forced renegotiations, delays or application denials. The November 16 report said a federal hearing in November would determine whether the case receives class-action status, which would allow the requested relief to extend beyond the named plaintiffs.
2 min

The opposition faction presented a plan to register qualifying European Union medicines without repeat laboratory testing and set a duty of AMD 50,000 (about $140).
2 min

Eligible US adults aged 21 or older can enroll with an Apple Intelligence-capable iPhone running iOS 26 or later. They can ask health questions, read answers with clinical citations and rate them. Apple says the app is not intended to diagnose or treat conditions.
2 min