Pakistan’s courts are under political control, jurists’ group says


The International Commission of Jurists says constitutional amendments and their implementation have impaired the courts’ ability to check the government and Parliament and provide remedies for human rights violations.
Pakistan’s constitutional amendments and their implementation have effectively placed the judiciary under the control of the political branches, the International Commission of Jurists said in an 18 November 2026 report. The group concluded that the highest courts no longer have the guarantees of independence required by international standards.
The commission, an international nongovernmental organization of judges, lawyers and legal scholars that works on human rights and judicial independence, said the changes marked a break from the model of judicial independence developed after the judiciary’s restoration in 2009.
The group said the courts’ ability to check the government and Parliament and provide remedies for human rights violations had been impaired. It said Pakistan is a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, whose Article 14 protects judicial independence and whose Article 2(3) guarantees an effective remedy for violations.
The 26th Amendment, passed in October 2024, created constitutional benches within the Supreme Court. Their members were chosen by a reconstituted Judicial Commission of Pakistan in which judges no longer held a majority.
The 27th Amendment established a separate Federal Constitutional Court in November 2025. Two senior Supreme Court judges resigned in protest on the day it became law.

An investigation published on 16 November said the men signed contracts with Russia’s Defense Ministry and returned to civilian life in Chechnya rather than being sent to fight in Ukraine.
The 26th and 27th amendments have done exactly what we feared: they have placed Pakistan’s highest courts under the control of the executive.
Pakistan’s government argued that the amendments would check judicial overreach, reduce case backlogs, address the perceived politicization of the Supreme Court’s original jurisdiction—the cases it can hear first—and give Parliament a role in judicial appointments comparable to that of legislatures elsewhere, Dawn said.
The commission acknowledged that judicial appointments lacked transparency and that the Supreme Court had encroached on the roles of Parliament and other institutions. It said those problems did not justify a judicial structure that it considered inconsistent with Pakistan’s international obligations.
The commission urged the government to review the amendments and their implementation through broad, transparent public consultation, and to revise or repeal provisions inconsistent with international standards on judicial independence. It also called on the government to seek technical assistance from the UN special rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers and invite the rapporteur to visit Pakistan.
For the Judicial Commission of Pakistan, the group recommended published, internationally compliant criteria as the sole basis for judicial nominations, transparent appointment procedures and published reasons for each appointment. It also urged the commission not to transfer high court judges without their consent.
The report called on the Supreme Judicial Council to define judicial inefficiency narrowly as serious incompetence that makes a judge unfit for duty. It also urged the Special Parliamentary Committee to use clear, transparent criteria and procedures for selecting the chief justices of the Supreme Court and Federal Constitutional Court and to publish its reasons.
While the amendments remain in force, the commission urged the higher courts to interpret and apply them as far as possible in a way consistent with judicial independence under the covenant.
3 min

Swedish diplomat Lars Danielsson will succeed David O’Sullivan and head the new office from 6 February 2027. It will coordinate work on sanctions against Russia and other countries.
3 min

The Office for Environmental Protection says Environment Secretary Angela Eagle failed to protect sites and Natural England failed to safeguard bird populations and habitat. Both authorities have two months to respond.
3 min