US music publishers seek 20% streaming revenue rate


Amazon proposes 13.4%, while Spotify, Apple, Pandora and Google seek 15.35% for 2028–2032 as the US Copyright Royalty Board considers new royalty rules.
US music publisher and songwriter groups propose a 20% revenue rate in the streaming royalty review for 2028–2032, alongside alternative minimum payments. Amazon seeks 13.4%, while Spotify, Apple, Pandora and Google favor 15.35%, according to Billboard’s 15 October report on their filings. These are competing proposals, not adopted rates.
The review, called Phonorecords V, follows a board-approved settlement reached in 2022 for 2023–2027. That settlement raises the headline rate—the percentage of a service’s US revenue used in the royalty calculation—to 15.35% by 2027. The new proceeding will determine streaming mechanical royalties for the following five years.
Mechanical royalties pay for reproductions of songs, including digital reproduction through streaming. They are distinct from performance royalties and make up roughly half of songwriters’ streaming income, Billboard reports. The three-judge US Copyright Royalty Board reviews mechanical rates every five years.
| Participant | Proposed rate |
|---|---|
| National Music Publishers’ Association and Nashville Songwriters Association International | 20% |
| Amazon | |

The National Music Publishers’ Association (NMPA), the US publishers’ trade body, filed jointly with the Nashville Songwriters Association International. Their proposal would first calculate a royalty pool using whichever of four measures produces the largest amount.
| Measure | Proposed amount |
|---|---|
| Service revenue | 20% |
| Total content cost—the amount services owe record labels | 40% |
| Subscriber count | $2.40 per subscriber |
| Number of plays | $0.004 per play |
Performance royalties would then be subtracted from that initial pool. But the remaining mechanical royalty pool could not fall below 50% of the initial amount. This floor would limit how far the performance-royalty deduction could reduce mechanical payments.
Amazon also proposes lower percentages for the part of the calculation linked to record-label payments, and no mechanical minimum for free, advertising-supported tiers.
| Service type | Existing percentage | Amazon’s proposal |
|---|---|---|
| Free, advertising-supported services | 26.2% | 22.8% |
| Bundles | 24.5% | 21.3% |
Apple argues that the existing framework has worked: publishers’ revenue has grown, songwriters remain motivated to create, services have invested in features and consumers retain varied streaming options. Pandora and Google also favor keeping most of the previous settlement, Billboard reports.
The current system does not set one fixed mechanical payment for each stream. It combines revenue, record-label payments and subscriber-based minimums. The previous settlement raised both subscriber minimums and the part linked to label payments.
The 2022 settlement allowed qualifying bundles—subscriptions combining music with other offerings—to pay lower music mechanical royalties than standalone music subscriptions. Billboard explains that the discount was designed to let services pay for both music rights and the other rights needed for a bundle.
In spring 2024, Spotify classified its Premium, Duo and Family plans as bundles after adding audiobooks. Billboard reported that this cut the songwriter royalty rate for premium-user streams by nearly half. Amazon Music’s Unlimited plan later became a bundle with Audible; Apple’s music service is available both separately and within a broader subscription bundle. Billboard describes this as the first rate-review round in which the main dispute has shifted from standalone subscriptions to bundles.
| Estimate by | Amount | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Billboard | $150 million less | A projection made at the time of Spotify’s change: lower US mechanical royalties from Premium, Duo and Family during the first 12 months of bundle rates, compared with keeping those plans unbundled. |
| NMPA | $500 million and counting | The association’s calculation, presented at its summer 2026 annual meeting and reported by Billboard, of royalties songwriters and publishers had missed out on from Amazon and Spotify since bundling began. |
The NMPA called Spotify’s change a “loophole” that harmed songwriters’ and publishers’ livelihoods. In their new filing, the publisher and songwriter groups argue that rates should not fall below what free-market negotiations would produce. They seek tighter bundle rules, pointing to reduced music-royalty revenue after Spotify and Amazon added audiobooks.
Spotify says it applied the agreed terms and now seeks to keep the bundle definition unchanged. Its filing argues that the previous settlement resulted from intensive, arm’s-length negotiations between experienced industry participants. Each party could have pursued a full evidentiary hearing instead, Spotify says, but chose to settle.
The existing rule charges streaming services 1.5% per month on overdue royalty payments. Amazon proposes exempting “good faith” underpayments from that fee, using interest or other remedies instead, according to Billboard’s account of its filing.
Pandora calls aspects of the existing late fees unreasonable and seeks an additional fee in the opposite direction: songwriters or other royalty recipients would face a charge if they received an overpayment and did not return it promptly. That proposal would add a consequence for recipients, rather than only for services that pay late.
Participants filed their opening submissions, called “direct cases,” on 5 October 2026, the deadline for those that had not settled. The filings opened discovery, when parties seek evidence for their cases. The Digital Media Association, which represents streaming services, called for a timely resolution in a 6 October statement without specifying a proposed rate.
Settlement remains possible: Billboard reports that more than half of past board proceedings across sales and streaming ended in agreements rather than trials. Timetables have also slipped. Phonorecords III rates for 2018–2022 were finalized after that period ended, requiring amended payments and nearly $400 million in corrections.
Unless the parties settle, a hearing is scheduled to begin on 22 March 2027, with the board’s initial determination due by 17 December 2027, Music Business Worldwide reported on 7 October. The new rates are intended to apply from 1 January 2028 through the end of 2032.
The program connects an artist family’s history across Persia, Armenia and Stuttgart with Armenian literature, an independence documentary, contemporary music and hands-on workshops.
2 min

The No. 1 debut gives the Swedish producer-songwriter his 29th chart leader as a producer and his 31st as a writer, one behind Paul McCartney.
3 min

The study also finds a lower cast-and-crew share on productions shot partially or primarily in the U.S. Those figures measure shares, not absolute job losses.
3 min