How the Prem rewards tries—even in a heavy defeat


Super Rugby and France’s Top 14 use a three-try margin, making the opponent’s scoring part of the bonus calculation.
The Prem’s try-bonus rule can reward a team even when it loses heavily. Super Rugby and France’s Top 14 instead tie the reward to the gap between the teams’ try totals. That gives a team a reason to limit its opponent’s tries as well as score its own.
BBC Sport explained the contrast in its 1 October 2026 report on comments by Leicester Tigers head coach Geoff Parling. Tries are a form of scoring in rugby. A try bonus adds a point toward a team’s league standing, separate from the points that decide the match score.
| Competition | Try-bonus threshold |
|---|---|
| Prem | Score at least four tries, regardless of the opponent’s try total. |
| Super Rugby | Score at least three more tries than the opponent. |
| France’s Top 14 | Score at least three more tries than the opponent. |
| Team | Result | Bonus points earned |
|---|---|---|
| Leicester Tigers | Lost 40–38 to Saracens | Two: one for tries scored and one for the narrow defeat |

Leicester and Saracens scored six tries each, so both cleared the Prem’s four-try threshold. Under a three-try-margin rule, neither team’s six tries would have met the bonus requirement: their try totals were equal. Leicester’s second bonus was a separate reward for losing by fewer than seven points.
Newcastle’s result illustrates the other side of the Prem rule. A large losing margin does not cancel the try bonus if a team reaches the scoring target.
Analysis
Parling told BBC Radio Leicester that the four-try target contributes to the Prem’s high-scoring style by making that attacking total a priority. BBC Sport reported a record 52 tries across the opening weekend’s five matches, with nine of the 10 teams scoring at least 24 points. Those records show how high the scoring was; they do not establish that the bonus rule caused it.
Parling was not arguing against attacking play. He wanted Leicester to use its attacking options without sacrificing the other parts of its game, and said a 15–13 match could still be a great contest. His objection was to rewarding a fixed try total even when a team had conceded enough points to lose heavily.
If you get beaten by 40 points and still score four tries, I don't think you should be rewarded for that.
Matching Philadelphia’s offer kept the center in Anaheim. ESPN says the deal also raised the benchmark for teammate Cutter Gauthier’s contract.
2 min

Seven teams will advance from the two groups. BBC Sport’s schedule pairs India with Australia for the opener and includes England’s first match in Zimbabwe since 2004.
2 min

The Commonwealth Games finalist says continuous urine leakage once limited her training. Surgery in 2013 brought relief, and Gynocare supported her schooling.
2 min
Corrected spelling and punctuation in the Armenian text.