US judge bars transfer of Princeton student Eva Yi Xie from district


Anthony Trenga’s November 20 order requires a government response to her detention challenge by 25 November at 17:00 local time (02:00 Yerevan time the next day); it does not order her release.
US District Judge Anthony Trenga has barred immigration authorities from moving Eva Yi Xie, a Princeton University neuroscience doctoral student, out of the Eastern District of Virginia without a further court order. His November 20 order also requires government respondents to answer her petition challenging her detention.
US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detained Xie, a third-year doctoral student, on 19 November at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport after she attended the Society for Neuroscience meeting. She is being held at an ICE facility in Chantilly, Virginia, her lawyer Kerry Doyle told The Daily Princetonian, Princeton’s student newspaper.
Earlier: US immigration authorities detain Princeton researcher, colleagues say
Xie’s lawyers are seeking her release through a habeas corpus petition, a request for a court to examine whether a person’s detention is legal. Doyle said they argue that ICE arrested Xie without a warrant even though her circumstances had not recently changed and she posed no imminent risk of leaving the country that would make a warrantless arrest necessary.
Princeton arranged for Doyle to represent Xie, and the Virginia-based law office of Parastoo Golesorkhi Zahedi is also representing her. Doyle said ICE had not told her why Xie was arrested. ICE and the Department of Homeland Security did not respond to requests for comment.

Princeton has arranged legal counsel for Eva Yi Xie, a neuroscience doctoral student whose colleagues say she was detained at a Washington-area airport while returning from a conference.
The detention challenge is separate from Xie’s pending asylum case in immigration court. Doyle said Xie entered the US legally from China as a minor in 2016 and her family applied for asylum within a year. Her original nonimmigrant status has expired, but Doyle said she has valid work authorization and no criminal record. Her immigration hearing is scheduled for January 2028.
Princeton Graduate School Dean Rodney Priestley said the university would stay in contact with Xie’s family, legal team and colleagues to provide support. He said he hoped she could soon resume her studies. Xie’s adviser, professor Carlos Brody, called her detention “wildly unfair” in a statement to The Daily Princetonian.
By the court’s deadline, the government must either file a notice saying the factual and legal issues do not materially differ from those in earlier cases named in the order, or oppose the petition and discuss its material differences from Hernandez v. Crawford. An opposition must include relevant documents about Xie’s immigration history, detention and removal proceedings.
If the government files an opposition, Xie may reply by 30 November at 17:00 local time (02:00 Yerevan time the next day). If it files a notice saying there are no material differences from Hernandez, the court will incorporate filings from that case and rule without further filings from the parties.
2 min