Trump administration seeks end to Alaska Senate election appeal


The Justice Department asked an appeals court to erase the earlier dismissal and return the case for dismissal as moot after Mary Peltola won the race.
Situation: Alaska's 2026 Senate election
The Trump administration asked a federal appeals court on 19 November to end its challenge to certification of Alaska’s US Senate election, after Democrat Mary Peltola won the race. The request is not itself a court dismissal.
A district judge had already dismissed the lawsuit, which sought to block certification if Republican incumbent Dan S. Sullivan lost. The Justice Department appealed that decision, but has now asked the Ninth Circuit to declare the case moot, or no longer requiring a decision, following the election result.
The department wants the appeals court to vacate the district court’s dismissal order and send the case back for dismissal as moot. That would erase the earlier dismissal rather than leave it in place, The Associated Press said.
At President Donald Trump’s direction, the Justice Department sued on 22 October, seeking to hold up certification if the incumbent lost while investigators determined whether voters had confused him with another candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.
Peltola, a former US representative, won 50.13% of the vote, more than all other candidates combined. Her margin over the incumbent also exceeded the votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.
On 1 November, US District Judge Sharon L. Gleason dismissed the complaint without allowing it to be amended. She wrote that separating ballots cast for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. for further investigation would violate Alaskans’ right to a secret ballot. The government appealed that day.

Two sources say investigators issued the subpoenas over the candidacy of a second Dan Sullivan. Democrat Mary Peltola won the Senate race, but a law-enforcement source says the inquiry continues.
Alaska’s lawyers called the administration’s lawsuit legally meritless and filed papers supporting its dismissal.
Alaska election officials had tried to exclude Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher, saying he had not filed a good-faith candidacy and intended to confuse voters. He won an appeal in state Superior Court, and the Alaska Supreme Court affirmed the ruling. The ballot listed him with no party preference and identified Dan S. Sullivan as the Republican incumbent.
The New York Times said documents appeared to show that Peltola’s campaign was involved in recruiting the second Sullivan. Peltola denied involvement in encouraging his candidacy, and he said he ran on his own.
Now that the election is over and the voters sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in, I’m eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans.
The Ninth Circuit must decide the department’s request. Alaska Public Media said on 13 November that final state certification was scheduled for 25 November and that there was then no apparent legal obstacle to it.
3 min

The Democrat will be the first Alaska Native to serve in the US Senate. Her victory leaves Democrats with a projected 56 seats to Republicans’ 44.
2 min

Judge Thomas Matthews said election workers lacked capacity to produce the records during the count. The public-records case does not decide the Senate race.
3 min