Trump orders contractors to flag congressional requests

Federal contractors and subcontractors must follow instructions to withhold communications the White House or an agency deems privileged. Agencies must consider sanctions for noncompliance, including possible contract termination or suspension from future awards.
In this article
President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14438 on 20 November, immediately requiring federal contractors and subcontractors to notify the White House and contracting agencies of pending or future congressional requests about their work or communications with the executive branch.
The order follows the midterm elections, after which Democrats are set to take control of both chambers of Congress in January. Democrats have said they will investigate the Trump administration, Reuters said.
Contractors must follow instructions to withhold communications that the White House or a contracting agency determines are protected by executive privilege, a protection for confidential executive-branch information. Agencies must coordinate responses and any assertions of privilege with the White House and contractors.
If a contractor or subcontractor does not comply, the contracting agency must consider appropriate action under applicable law. Possible measures include terminating or canceling contracts and suspending or debarring contractors from future awards; none is automatic.
The White House’s case and the courts
The White House says coordination protects confidential information, including national and homeland security work, and avoids duplicative litigation and wasted effort. It argues that uncertainty over confidentiality could deter agencies from sharing sensitive information with contractors.
The order asserts that Congress needs a valid legislative purpose that does not intrude on core executive functions to seek information from agencies, employees or contractors. It also asserts that Congress cannot obtain privileged information shared with contractors before the executive branch has an opportunity to assert privilege.
In United States v. Nixon in 1974, the Supreme Court recognized a qualified executive privilege but ordered the production of presidential tapes for a criminal trial, where a specific need for evidence outweighed a general confidentiality claim. In Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP in 2020, the court required closer attention to separation-of-powers concerns in congressional subpoenas for a sitting president’s unprivileged personal financial records held by third parties. The court vacated the lower-court judgments and remanded the case for reconsideration. It rejected both automatic presidential immunity and unchecked deference to Congress. Neither case decided the order’s general claim about executive-branch communications with federal contractors.
Before the order, White House counsel Will Scharf warned Representative Robert Garcia that Democratic investigations without a legitimate legislative purpose could expose lawmakers to criminal inquiry. Garcia said the warning infringed on congressional oversight. Georgetown University law professor Josh Chafetz said Scharf’s letter identified no specific crime, the Los Angeles Times said.
What agencies must do next
Agencies must promptly tell contractors and subcontractors about their obligations and take steps to make prime contractors responsible for subcontractor compliance. The Office of Management and Budget must develop guidance on compliance and coordination among agencies, contractors and the White House.
Trump invoked the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act among his authorities for the order. The order says it must be implemented consistently with applicable law and subject to available appropriations.
Follow AveNews
Earlier in Politics
RightsUS judge approves Bayer’s $7.25 billion Roundup settlement
The agreement covers claims by people who say the weedkiller caused their non-Hodgkin lymphoma, including some diagnosed in the future. The ruling can still be appealed.
2 min
SecurityUS Sen. Thom Tillis holds up Michael LoSapio’s cyber agency nomination
The nominee’s refusal to call the 6 January Capitol attack an attack prompted the Republican’s hold, which will keep him out of a planned December package vote before the Senate majority changes.
3 min
RightsLos Angeles jury convicts Jonathan Rinderknecht on two arson charges
The verdict follows a deadlocked first trial over fires prosecutors linked to the Palisades blaze, which killed 12 people. Sentencing is set for 17 March 2027.
2 min
Sources
Show all 5 sourcesShow fewer
The White HousePROTECTING THE EXECUTIVE’S PRIVILEGES AND ENHANCING EFFICIENCIES IN FEDERAL CONTRACTING (opens in a new tab)
- d2233.cms.socastsrm.comTrump order says contractors must notify White House of congressional probes | MWC Sandbox/Syndication (opens in a new tab)
- grokipedia.comUnited States v. Nixon (opens in a new tab)
- grokipedia.comTrump v. Mazars USA, LLP (opens in a new tab)
- latimes.comWhite House warns of criminal inquiries into House Democrats who investigate Trump - Los Angeles Times (opens in a new tab)
