US judge limits agriculture secretary’s religious emails


Judge Trina L. Thompson’s preliminary injunction requires Brooke Rollins to follow her department’s workplace guidance, including a ban on using official authority to pressure subordinates.
US District Judge Trina L. Thompson issued a preliminary injunction on 19 November limiting Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins’s religious communications to employees. Thompson found that Rollins’s Christmas 2025 and Easter 2026 emails created enough pressure to conform to raise a violation of the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause.
The messages went to about 100,000 Agriculture Department employees. The clause says Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.
Thompson pointed to Rollins’s authority over employees, her use of an official account for department-wide messages and language that implied recipients shared her Christian beliefs. The Christmas message included a video referring to Jesus Christ as “our Savior”; the Easter email called the resurrection “the foundation of our faith.”
Employees were expected to read messages from the same account because it also carried important information about matters such as reorganization and shutdown planning, Thompson said. She extended the order’s protection to employees who were not part of the suit because workers cannot opt out of the secretary’s messages, Courthouse News Service said.
Drawing on Rollins’s own workplace guidance, Thompson ordered her to stop religious communication if a colleague asks her to stop, avoid creating a hostile work environment through persistent unwelcome advances and refrain from using official authority to pressure subordinates.
Rollins may still discuss her beliefs with interested colleagues, explain why her faith matters to her, politely invite coworkers to religious events and express religious views in appropriate conversations. Thompson said the court expressed no view on what Rollins may do in her personal capacity.
The National Federation of Federal Employees and individual department employees sued Rollins and the department in federal court in Northern California. They alleged that the messages pressured workers to conform to her beliefs and asked the court to stop messages promoting or favoring a particular religion during the litigation.
At the hearing, Justice Department lawyer Elisabeth Neylan argued that the messages followed a tradition of officials invoking religion. She said they conveyed holiday wishes and Rollins’s beliefs without asking employees to perform religious acts.
I am heartened and relieved to see the court upholding the Constitution and protecting employees from further inappropriate messages from the Secretary.
Randy Erwin, president of the plaintiff union, called the ruling an important victory for the First Amendment.
Thompson dismissed the plaintiffs’ separate Administrative Procedure Act claim, finding that the emails were neither a final agency action nor an order. The preliminary injunction applies while the lawsuit continues.
Kyiv’s military administration reported fires in residential buildings in 2 districts after the overnight attack; Ukraine’s president and European leaders have called on Russia to accept a limited ceasefire.
2 min

The Guardian reported on 19 November that the EU dropped its demand for home fees for its students at British universities. Negotiators also provisionally agreed a 100,000 annual youth mobility cap, while the wider deal remains unsettled.
2 min

The letter of intent would allow Japan’s forces to train at Indian firing ranges for the first time, including with surface-to-ship missiles; both sides agreed to speed up coordination.
2 min