Wandering black holes could help trace galaxy histories

An ASTRID simulation study explores how black-hole origins and later galaxy mergers could leave different clues in where black holes end up.

An ASTRID simulation study explores how black-hole origins and later galaxy mergers could leave different clues in where black holes end up.
Comparing black holes at galaxy centers with those away from the center could help distinguish how black holes formed from how their host galaxies later changed, according to an ASTRID simulation study. The researchers investigated whether some wandering black holes were once central supermassive black holes displaced by galaxy mergers.
Universe Today reported the study on October 7, 2026. Led by Yale astronomy doctoral candidate Emma Jane Weller, the team included Priyamvada Natarajan and Colin J. Burke. The results were published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.
Scientists have competing explanations for the early “seeds” that grew into supermassive black holes. One proposes that the first generation of stars, called Population III, left small black holes that later merged. Another proposes that large amounts of pristine gas collapsed directly into heavier black-hole seeds. The study explores whether clues to those beginnings can survive billions of years of subsequent galaxy evolution.
ASTRID models the evolution of stars, gas, dark matter and black holes. The team traced galaxies over about 12.6 billion years. Their stellar masses—the combined mass of their stars—ranged from 10 million to 1 trillion times the Sun’s mass.
Crucially, ASTRID does not automatically put black holes at galaxy centers. It models the gravitational forces that move them through their surroundings and toward the center. This lets researchers distinguish centered black holes from wanderers rather than assigning all black holes a central position. Being off-center does not, by itself, mean that a black hole is unbound from every galaxy.
In the simulations, low-mass galaxies appeared to retain information about their original black-hole seeds even after billions of years of growth through mergers. The researchers also found that the process producing wanderers was more pronounced in these galaxies, where gravity is weaker. Natarajan argued that comparing centered and wandering black holes could help separate clues to their birth from the effects of later events in their host galaxies.
The simulations suggested another distinction: low-mass galaxies that had stopped forming stars were more likely to contain centered black holes, while those still forming stars were more likely to contain wanderers. These are predictions about simulated populations, not a measured distribution of black holes in real galaxies.
The researchers propose looking for these clues through deep X-ray observations, radio astronomy, and optical and infrared spectroscopy—the study of light separated into its wavelengths. Brief flares produced when black holes consume stars offer another possible route. Weller said combining observations with simulations may help identify distinct traces of black-hole formation and galaxy evolution.

A comparison of two valleys suggests flexible vocal behaviour, not evolutionary change. A separate study projects shrinking suitable habitat under several climate scenarios.
3 min

Stopping the twice-yearly clock changes still leaves a choice about when daylight falls relative to work and school.

Operators could submit applications electronically and combine three required safety analyses into one submission. Public comments are open through November 4.
2 min
3 min