Simulations link Webb’s red dots to primordial-star black holes


Daniel Whalen’s team proposes that black holes left by collapsing supermassive primordial stars power the compact red objects; the model is not an observational identification.
Computer simulations suggest that the James Webb Space Telescope’s Little Red Dots could be galaxies powered by black holes left behind when supermassive primordial stars collapsed, a possible explanation for their unusual light rather than an identification of how the black holes formed.
Webb revealed numerous small-appearing red objects in December 2022. They are only a few hundred light-years across but as bright as much larger galaxies, with unusual V-shaped spectra—the pattern of their light across wavelengths. Daniel Whalen, who led the simulations, said their X-ray and radio emissions have not been detectable.
The objects’ abundance has challenged astronomers’ ideas about how quickly galaxies and black holes formed. If all their light came from stars, some galaxies would have had to grow too large, too quickly for existing theories to explain, NASA said. Black holes drawing in gas could provide some of the light without requiring as many stars.
Whalen, of the University of Portsmouth’s Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, led the international study, which appeared in The Astrophysical Journal Letters, Universe Today said. The team proposes that the dots have active galactic nuclei: energetic regions at the centers of galaxies, powered by gas falling onto black holes.
In the model, dense disks of gas largely conceal the black holes. The gas traps high-energy X-rays while letting some visible, ultraviolet and infrared light escape. A dense cluster of stars in the disk produces the blue part of the spectrum, the team’s model suggests.

The team says the gas-envelope model’s light signatures fit Webb’s observations. Whalen said the dots might offer a view of the birth of the first supermassive black holes, though the modeled match does not identify their origin observationally.
The team estimates central black holes of about 10 million solar masses, rather than directly measuring them. Its modeled disks contain around 100 million stars in regions about 500 light-years across, estimates rather than counts of individual stars.
Astronomers have also proposed compact groups of stars, dusty galaxies, supermassive stars and quasi-stars—hypothetical objects with a black hole inside a massive envelope of gas, powered primarily by accretion rather than nuclear fusion. Another proposed route begins with the direct collapse of a massive gas cloud into a black-hole seed, an initial black hole that can grow supermassive. A match between a model and the observed light does not by itself establish which explanation, or which black-hole formation route, is correct. For the Little Red Dot Abell 2744–QSO1, observations of gas motion yielded a dynamical measurement of its central black hole at approximately 50 million solar masses; that measurement does not establish how it formed.
In a survey described by NASA in January 2025, a team led by Dale Kocevski found that Little Red Dots appeared in large numbers around 600 million years after the Big Bang and declined rapidly around 1.5 billion years afterward. The team used data from several Webb surveys. About 70% of targets with available spectroscopy from the Red Unknowns: Bright Infrared Extragalactic Survey (RUBIES) showed rapidly orbiting gas, a sign of a disk around a supermassive black hole.
Kocevski’s team is examining the objects’ mid-infrared light and looking for growing black holes that meet the criteria for Little Red Dots. NASA also identified deeper spectroscopy and selected follow-up observations as useful ways to investigate their nature.
The agency says foreign regulators can use its assessments when considering medicines for sale. The program began with a tentative approval for the HIV medicine lenacapavir.
3 min

A USC Norman Lear Center and Good Energy study found climate terms in 3.2% of 35,120 scripts from 2021–24, up from 2.8%, using the same keywords as its earlier 2016–20 analysis.
1 min

About 20 Awá living in voluntary isolation approached Guajajara villagers in Brazil on 16 November. Brazil’s Indigenous affairs agency says its teams are monitoring the situation and reviewing information about the group’s health.
2 min