Niobium clues lead researchers to propose a second-generation planet


Unusual chemistry around white dwarf HS 0209+0832 may trace a world made from the star’s expelled material. The planet and its proposed origin remain unconfirmed.
Astronomers have matched long-unexplained features in Hubble Space Telescope observations to niobium, a chemical element. In a study published in Nature Astronomy on October 5, the researchers interpret its unusually high abundance around white dwarf HS 0209+0832 as a clue to a possible planet formed after the star’s death, according to NASA’s account of the research.
A white dwarf is the core left behind when a low-mass star exhausts its nuclear fuel and sheds its outer layers of gas and dust. Earth and the other planets in our solar system formed from material left over from the Sun’s birth. The proposed “second-generation” planet would instead have formed from material expelled by the dying star—a different route to making a world. Neither the planet nor that origin is confirmed.
Hubble first observed the star in 1999, recording roughly 100 chemical features that could not be identified. Lead author Jamie Williams, a doctoral candidate at the University of Warwick, reexamined those records using an updated chemical database. Niobium matched many of the unexplained features.
A spectrum records light separated by wavelength. Dips in Hubble’s spectrum mark where elements absorb light, reducing the amount reaching the telescope. The team also found strong niobium signatures in observations from NASA’s retired Far Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer, or FUSE. Those observations corroborate the chemical finding, rather than directly confirming a planet.
NASA’s Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite, or TESS, observed the white dwarf for four months and detected periodic changes in its brightness. The researchers interpret those changes as evidence of a planet orbiting about 3.7 million miles (6 million kilometers) from the star, much closer than Mercury orbits the Sun.

Unusual chemistry and a roughly 4.4-day brightness cycle around a white dwarf could indicate a gas giant formed from the star’s expelled material. The planet remains unconfirmed.
Analysis
The researchers link the high niobium abundance to chemically enriched material expelled during the star’s death. Team member Nicholas Stone, a theoretical astrophysicist at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, explains that niobium and other elements heavier than iron form under unusual conditions inside dying stars, rather than through the fusion reactions that produce many common elements in stellar cores. The team proposes that some of the expelled material gathered into a gas giant planet.
The team estimates that the candidate planet is about the size of Jupiter and is rapidly losing its atmosphere. In the proposed explanation, the relatively young white dwarf is still hot enough for its radiation to strip the planet’s outer material. That material could form a comet-like tail, collect in a disk around the white dwarf and fall onto its surface. This would account for the niobium Hubble detected while observing the star.
Williams says questions remain about how second-generation planets form, how common they are and how their orbits evolve. He plans to use Hubble over the next several years to gather more observations of such systems.
3 min

A theoretical study explores how Sagittarius A* might accelerate particles, with predicted gamma-ray and neutrino signals offering a possible test.
3 min

The research points to a tradeoff: reducing production of cancer-killing proteins may preserve immune cells, but could weaken their attack. Patient benefit remains unproven.
3 min
Correction ·
Corrected spelling and punctuation in the Armenian text.