Ottawa researchers report tests of alternative cosmology

A fitted version of the model described galaxy rotation curves comparably to another approach, with no statistically significant difference in fit quality. Other tests include an unreviewed supernova preprint, while a further test remains unpublished.
In this article
University of Ottawa researchers Rajendra Gupta and Nikolaos Samaras have reported tests of an alternative model of the universe against astronomical observations in 2025–26. Their reported agreement does not establish the model, which proposes an alternative to dark matter and dark energy.
The work follows Gupta’s 2023 paper, which proposed a hybrid expanding-universe model and reported that it fitted supernova data and was compatible with James Webb Space Telescope observations of early galaxies. Gupta is an adjunct physics professor and Samaras a postdoctoral researcher at Ottawa.
What the model changes
The model, called covarying coupling constants plus tired light, or CCC+TL, divides the observed shift of light toward longer wavelengths, known as redshift, between cosmic expansion and a proposed tired-light effect. It also proposes that fundamental constants governing how forces and particles interact change together.
In the standard model, known as ΛCDM, dark matter contributes to the gravitational clustering of matter, while dark energy drives accelerated expansion. CCC+TL instead proposes that changing constants could account for effects attributed to both. CCC+TL estimates the universe’s age at about 26.7 billion years, compared with approximately 13.8 billion years in standard cosmology, potentially giving early galaxies more time to form.
Galaxy rotation and the Bullet Cluster
In a 2026 paper in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, the researchers said a fitted version of the covarying-constants model performed comparably to a galaxy-by-galaxy fit using Modified Newtonian Dynamics when both approaches used observed rotation curves to predict the contribution of ordinary matter. The difference in their measures of fit quality was not statistically significant.
The SPARC database contains 175 disk galaxies; the paper includes supplementary rotation curves for 165.
The researchers also said the model’s extra gravitational effect was consistent with observations of the Bullet Cluster, calling the result an early proof of concept. In that pair of merging galaxy clusters, X-ray observations locate hot gas separately from mass peaks inferred from gravitational lensing—the bending of light from background galaxies. The separation tests competing accounts of gravity and unseen matter.
A dispute over expansion measurements
An independent analysis led by Lei Lei found that the CCC+TL parameters fitted to Type Ia supernova data failed to reproduce expansion-rate measurements from cosmic chronometers. These measurements use differences in the ages of quiet galaxies to estimate how fast the universe expanded. The analysis favored ΛCDM for those measurements.
In a 2026 follow-up in the same journal, Gupta argued that chronometer age calibrations rely on standard models of stellar evolution. He said a proposed correction reduced the apparent disagreement, but that the relevant stellar models would need to be recalculated within CCC+TL.
Gupta and Samaras also tested the model against predicted abundances of hydrogen, helium and other light elements shortly after the Big Bang, Universe Today said. Such abundance calculations probe early expansion and nuclear reactions.
Supernovae and further tests
In a separate public preprint pending review, Gupta and Samaras worked with Utkarsh Kumar, an Ottawa postdoctoral researcher in observational cosmology, to test how supernova light curves stretch over time. The authors said Dark Energy Survey observations exclude a redshift with no such time stretching, but do not exclude the hybrid expansion–tired-light models they tested: their modeled 95% bands overlap the observed relation.
Gupta also said the model meets a test involving the cosmic microwave background, relic radiation whose temperature fluctuations carry information about the early universe. Unlike the supernova preprint, that test is yet to be published.
Gupta predicts galaxies exist well beyond the distances Webb has reached. Webb’s GLIMPSE program has already used the lensing effect of the Abell S1063 galaxy cluster to identify an initial sample of about 540 candidate galaxies at redshifts between 6 and 16; its first data release is public. Further observations could test Gupta’s prediction.
Follow AveNews
Earlier in Science
EarthAncient rocks point to two episodes of mountain growth
A study published on 13 November proposes that taller mountains supplied ocean nutrients that could have helped oxygenate Earth and create conditions for complex life.
3 min
EarthGlaciers ending in lakes lose ice fastest in global study
From 2000 to 2020, glaciers lost an average of 66 centimeters of water equivalent a year where they ended in lakes, compared with 40 on land and 36 at sea. To explain ice loss in lake-ending glaciers, the study’s model assigned 46% of the influence it accounted for to topography, about 43% to climate and about 11% to lakes.
3 min
Physics, Maths & DiscoveriesStanford professor Vakil posts proposed proof of generalized Riemann hypothesis
The Stanford professor says Alessandro Masullo wrote the draft without superintelligence and has asked mathematicians to check it; independent verification remains outstanding.
2 min
Sources
Show all 11 sourcesShow fewer
Universe TodayA Radical Theory about the Universe Just Passed Some Key Tests. So... What Does that Mean? (opens in a new tab)
- arxiv.org[2606.27391] Testing the CCC+TL cosmology with cosmic-chronometer measurements of the Hubble parameter (opens in a new tab)
- arxiv.org[2608.11575] Testing Covarying Coupling Constants (CCC) against the full SPARC rotation-curve sample: a like-for-like comparison with MOND and NFW (opens in a new tab)
- arxiv.org[2309.13100] JWST early Universe observations and ΛCDM cosmology (opens in a new tab)
- arxiv.org[2609.10582] Supernova Time Dilation in Hybrid Expansion-Tired-Light Cosmologies (opens in a new tab)
- grokipedia.comLambda-CDM model (opens in a new tab)
- grokipedia.comBullet Cluster (opens in a new tab)
- arxiv.org[2508.04277] Stringent constraint on the CCC+TL cosmology with $H(z)$ Measurements (opens in a new tab)
- grokipedia.comBig Bang nucleosynthesis (opens in a new tab)
- grokipedia.comCosmic microwave background (opens in a new tab)
- arxiv.org[2511.07542] JWST's GLIMPSE: an overview of the deepest probe of early galaxy formation and cosmic reionization (opens in a new tab)
