Apple’s Full Disk Access plans: expert questions Meta’s claim on Muse

A security expert says the macOS permission can make chat files readable at the system level. Meta says Muse also needs its own Messages setting enabled.

A security expert says the macOS permission can make chat files readable at the system level. Meta says Muse also needs its own Messages setting enabled.
An app’s own Messages setting does not establish how much macOS lets it read through Full Disk Access. macOS security expert Patrick Wardle told Ars Technica that the system-level permission makes any non-root file readable, including chats, browser cookies and browsing history.
Apple says it will introduce controls requiring “very explicit user action” before an app can receive Full Disk Access on macOS. The planned change aims to ensure Mac users understand how much personal data they are allowing an app to access, according to TechCrunch’s October 2 report.
Full Disk Access gives an app permission to access files, mail, messages and browsing history, Apple explains. The setting was designed to let backups work properly. Users can already grant desktop superintelligence (SI) agents—SI apps that can act on a computer—broader access to personal content by changing macOS settings.
In a blog post addressed to developers, Apple warned that some developers use Full Disk Access in ways that could expose the contents of users’ systems without their full knowledge and understanding. Apple expects the risks associated with that access to grow substantially as SI agents become more capable and more able to act on their own.
TechCrunch also described a disputed account from Inc. columnist Jason Aten. Aten claimed that Meta’s Muse app knew the contents of his private messages even though he had not given it permission. Meta disputed the claim. Muse optionally lets users enable Full Disk Access, TechCrunch reported.
Asked by Ars Technica why Full Disk Access would not let Muse read messages, Meta repeated CTO David Singleton’s claim that Muse can read Messages content only if both macOS Full Disk Access and the Messages connector—a setting inside Muse—are enabled. Wardle’s technical explanation does not establish what Muse actually read in Aten’s case. Apple named no app or developer in its statement.
TechCrunch separately cited a Wired report that a flaw in ChatGPT’s Mac app could have allowed hackers to access sensitive data. Neither that reported vulnerability nor the disputed Muse account establishes that it caused Apple’s decision.
What remains uncertain
The specific steps users will need to take, the macOS version that will include the controls and the release timetable are not yet clear. Apple did not respond to TechCrunch’s inquiry about the change.

Meta says users must enable both Full Disk Access and its Messages connector. Journalist Jason Aten’s account conflicts with that explanation.
2 min