Researchers find little forest growth in 50 Australian credit projects


Andrew Macintosh’s team says tree cover increased only slightly over five wet years in areas used to generate carbon credits. Project developers dispute the findings.
Researchers led by Australian National University professor Andrew Macintosh say they found only a small increase in forest and tree crown cover across 50 Australian forest regeneration project areas over five years of wet conditions. The projects generate carbon credits that companies can use toward required emissions cuts.
Under the regeneration method, land managers change practices to allow suppressed native forest to regrow and can earn credits when eligible activities store carbon. The method closed to new registrations on 30 September 2023, but projects that had already begun their crediting period can continue for that period.
The Australian Conservation Foundation released the research in a report on 18 November, The Guardian said. Green Collar, a carbon-credit project manager that rejected the findings, said the report had not been publicly released or published in a peer-reviewed journal.
Report author Professor David Eldridge, a former principal research scientist with the New South Wales environment department, called areas northwest of Bourke “phantom forests.”
Some of these areas have never grown forests; they will never grow forests

Green Collar said evidence on the ground showed its projects were working. It said the researchers used satellite images and a single field visit, and argued that satellite canopy measurements do not capture wood and roots, where it said most of the carbon is stored. Skye Glenday, chief executive of fellow developer Climate Friendly, said the criticism conflicted with the facts and the independent scientific and regulatory scrutiny applied to projects.
In a separate 2024 journal study of 182 regeneration projects, researchers found limited evidence of regeneration in credited areas. They said changes in woody vegetation cover largely mirrored changes in adjacent areas outside the projects.
The Clean Energy Regulator said it had confidence in the regeneration method and took concerns about credit projects seriously. It said projects must demonstrate increasing canopy cover every five years and that it had rejected noncompliant areas that could have received 6.7 million credits.
The regulator says it assesses evidence at required checks before issuing credits and requires noncompliance identified through an audit of those checks to be addressed before further credits are issued.
Macintosh said the projects had generated more than 60 million carbon credits worth up to $2 billion.
Australia’s Safeguard Mechanism allows covered industrial companies to buy an unlimited number of credits to count toward required emissions cuts while they continue to emit. The foundation wants coal and gas companies barred from claiming offsets as their own cuts; its report argues that cheap, low-integrity credits can make offsets less expensive than direct cuts and undermine the policy.
The Australian government is reviewing the Safeguard Mechanism, as required by legislation.
In countries’ self-assessments, 22% said their plans had both necessary funding and full implementation, while 36% reported a national reference laboratory equipped to test selected bacteria and fungi.
2 min

Researchers used an insulated chamber to transmit information without an actively generated radio signal. They plan to test the system in noisier settings and with multiple transmitters.
3 min

Anutin Charnvirakul ordered alternative supplies and close monitoring after water was suspended to 14 villages where arsenic at the local waterworks reached 30 times the safe limit.
3 min