High Court dismisses Mount Pleasant coal expansion appeal

The court found that NSW planners failed to consider conditions to minimise emissions from burning the mine’s coal overseas.

The court found that NSW planners failed to consider conditions to minimise emissions from burning the mine’s coal overseas.
Australia’s High Court has dismissed MACH Energy’s appeal by 3–2 and found the approval for its Mount Pleasant coal mine expansion invalid, the Guardian reported on 7 October. The mine is in Muswellbrook, in New South Wales (NSW).
The appeal followed a 2025 NSW Court of Appeal decision that overturned the expansion approval. The High Court found the approval invalid on a different basis: the state’s Independent Planning Commission had failed to consider conditions aimed at minimising emissions from the coal’s overseas combustion to the greatest extent possible.
The Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group brought the original case. The group had pursued the challenge through the courts for more than four years, after the Land and Environment Court initially ruled in MACH Energy’s favour.
The proposed expansion would double Mount Pleasant’s coal output to 21 million tonnes a year through 2048. About 98% of its projected emissions are “scope 3” emissions—indirect emissions that, in this case, arise when customers burn the exported coal overseas. The assessment duty therefore covers the largest share of the project’s projected emissions, not just emissions produced at the mine.
The Guardian reports that advocates describe the ruling as a binding national precedent for fossil-fuel projects in NSW. The finding concerns the NSW planning commission’s duty to consider emissions-reduction conditions; it is not a nationwide ban on coal projects.
A MACH Energy spokesperson said the company was disappointed but accepted the decision. The ruling concerns the expansion approval, not an order to close the operating mine. The spokesperson said a separate modification approved by the state government in August would extend the existing operation’s life by six years.
MACH Energy said it would review the judgment to understand its implications for future project assessments and environmental approvals. The company also said it would pursue all available options to maintain the operation over the long term and work with regulators, governments and local communities on the decision’s practical implications.

An ASTRID simulation study explores how black-hole origins and later galaxy mergers could leave different clues in where black holes end up.
3 min

A comparison of two valleys suggests flexible vocal behaviour, not evolutionary change. A separate study projects shrinking suitable habitat under several climate scenarios.
3 min

Stopping the twice-yearly clock changes still leaves a choice about when daylight falls relative to work and school.
3 min