Lecturer Barbara O’Neill advises stopping thyroid medicine, Guardian reports


The Guardian reports advice to stop prescribed thyroid medicine and blood-sugar checks at her Cheshire retreat. The organisers say they will continue holding events.
Barbara O’Neill advised a woman who said she had no functioning thyroid to gradually stop her prescribed medicine, the Guardian reported in an undercover feature published on 18 October. The feature also describes O’Neill telling an attendee with diabetes to stop checking her blood sugar at a five-day wellness retreat at De Vere Cranage Estate in Cheshire.
The Guardian’s reporter attended one day and observed four sessions. The feature says residential tickets could cost up to £1,300.
In 2019, the New South Wales Health Care Complaints Commission permanently prohibited O’Neill from providing any health services, paid or voluntary. The regulator found that she made dangerous claims unsupported by evidence and posed a risk to public safety. It found that she misled vulnerable people, including mothers and cancer patients, with selective information and discouraged mainstream cancer treatment, antibiotics and vaccination. The prohibition applies throughout Australia but not overseas.
According to the Guardian, O’Neill recommended that the woman without a functioning thyroid slowly stop taking thyroxine, her prescribed thyroid medicine, to “see what the body does”. Martin Whyte, a professor of metabolic medicine at the University of Surrey, told the newspaper that someone without a functioning thyroid cannot make thyroid hormone. Stopping thyroxine therefore risks serious, potentially life-threatening illness, he said.

Another woman said she had diabetes and hoped to stop taking metformin, a medicine that lowers blood sugar. O’Neill advised her to stop testing her blood sugar, claiming it would “balance right out with the change in diet”, the Guardian reported. Metformin is usually used for type 2 diabetes, which can respond to dietary changes. Type 1 diabetes requires daily insulin injections; both types require blood-sugar monitoring.
Gill Livingston, a professor of psychiatry of older people at UCL, called the diabetes advice “very dangerous”. She explained that untreated high blood sugar increases the risk of problems including loss of eyesight, loss of sensation in the limbs, dementia and sometimes death. Her warning concerned the potential consequences of untreated diabetes, not a reported outcome for the attendee.
During the question-and-answer session, a woman said tests had found a stomach tumour and two specialists had recommended surgery. O’Neill replied that scans were sometimes wrong and recommended putting kitchen paper soaked in castor oil on the outside of the body. She also recommended castor-oil compresses for nasal polyps, endometriosis, carpal tunnel syndrome and bile duct stones. Medical experts told the Guardian there was no evidence that the compresses improved those conditions.
At the end of the day, an attendee told the undercover reporter that O’Neill’s answer had given her confidence to go against specialists’ advice to have surgery for a health condition. The attendee described an intention to reject that advice, rather than a completed refusal of surgery or a resulting medical outcome.
The Guardian reported on 2 October that health experts had written to venues hosting O’Neill’s UK and Ireland engagements. O’Neill lectures internationally on “natural self-healing” and describes herself as a naturopath and nutritionist. Dr David Robert Grimes, a science communicator and biostatistics expert at Trinity College Dublin, organised the letter. It accused O’Neill of giving unqualified medical advice and attacking conventional treatment, and warned that respected venues could lend her claims an appearance of legitimacy.
The Guardian’s 2 October account listed the engagements below. It quoted £700 for the five-day Cheshire retreat and described lectures, talks by O’Neill’s husband, Michael, and a dinner dance. The 18 October feature gives a residential ticket price of up to £1,300.
| Event | Venue | Schedule given on 2 October |
|---|---|---|
| A Taste of Misty Mountain | Cranage Estate, Cheshire, UK | Five days in early October |
| Multi-day event organised by Balm of Gilead, a Christian health and wellness group | City North hotel and conference centre, Gormanston, Ireland | Mid-October |
| Founders and Future festival, featuring Barbara and Michael O’Neill | Glasgow University Union, UK | No date specified |
De Vere Cranage Estate said it hosted events for private clients, organisations and businesses and would not normally become involved in their content or opinions. Glasgow University Union president Cameron MacKenzie said externally organised events were neither affiliated with nor endorsed by its board. He said the festival organisers could use the booked spaces if they complied with booking terms, internal policies and applicable law, and that nothing outlined appeared to breach those requirements.
In the 2 October report, Michael O’Neill disputed the prohibition, claiming it had “serious legal flaws” under investigation and alleging bias against natural wellness practitioners. He also claimed Barbara had never received a patient complaint of harm and described the complaints as ideological rather than factual. The commission maintained that its findings justified the permanent prohibition.
Prof David Elliman, a consultant at Great Ormond Street hospital, told the Guardian that science did not support O’Neill’s suggestions. He warned that following her advice instead of medical guidance supported by scientific evidence would be dangerous and result in some deaths. The Australian commission urged attendees to check O’Neill’s advice with a registered health practitioner.
Responding to the Guardian’s questions about the retreat, Michael O’Neill, who co-runs the company and organises the tours, described the complaints as speculative and rooted in an ideology that only the medical profession offers legitimate routes to health. He claimed the couple had received no complaints about Barbara’s work and characterised the criticism as a campaign supporting the pharmaceutical industry.
Barbara and Michael O’Neill vowed to continue holding events, the Guardian reported on 18 October.
The movement patterns may help explain how a related species reaches the brain, but the experiments did not demonstrate infection.
2 min

A Texas family received conflicting explanations for a prescription delay: insurance preapproval or a missing diagnostic code. Responsibility remains unresolved.
3 min

Record-low river flows, widespread drought and severe fire weather added pressure on transport, crops and water supplies.
4 min