Hexagonal fossil burrows point to arthropods, study argues

More than 1,000 measurements offer clues to who made Paleodictyon, a burrow pattern also found in modern oceans whose makers remain unseen.

More than 1,000 measurements offer clues to who made Paleodictyon, a burrow pattern also found in modern oceans whose makers remain unseen.
A study published in Earth-Science Reviews argues that an unidentified marine arthropod most likely built the hexagonal burrow networks called Paleodictyon. The researchers measured fossil tunnels to test a longstanding explanation for a pattern whose makers have never been observed, Eos reported on 6 October.
In Italy’s Apennine mountains, these networks are preserved in sedimentary rock that was once the seafloor. Similar burrows occur in modern oceans. Researchers have proposed makers ranging from worms to corals and algae, as well as arthropods—animals with hard outer skeletons and jointed limbs, including crustaceans.
Paleodictyon is a trace fossil: it preserves evidence of an organism’s activity rather than its body. Such traces can reveal how ancient animals lived, even when the animals themselves are unknown.
Andrea Baucon, a paleontologist at the University of Cagliari, and colleagues took more than 1,000 measurements of interior angles, distances between the hexagons’ corners and burrow widths. They examined specimens held at the University of Genoa and the Natural History Museum of Piacenza, alongside specimens the team found in Apennine rock outcrops.
| Measurement | Reported result |
|---|---|
| Interior angles | Average deviation of 8.5° from a regular hexagon’s 120° angle |
| Side lengths within a network | Average variation of 0.5 millimeter |
Analysis
The team interprets the straight tunnels and sharp intersections as evidence favoring a hard-bodied arthropod. Baucon said worms and other soft-bodied creatures tend to follow wandering paths of least resistance. The researchers link Paleodictyon’s geometry to the hard outer skeletons and jointed limbs that allow arthropods to make straight tracks and sharp turns. That is an explanation inferred from the burrows, not an observation of their maker moving.
The researchers also observed that small deviations in side lengths and angles did not spread through the network. Baucon interprets this as possible evidence that the maker could detect and correct mistakes while keeping track of direction and distance. The measured pattern supports that possibility, but error correction and the animal’s mental abilities were not directly observed.
Two specialists who were not involved in the study saw value in its case. Andrew Gooday, a marine biologist and emeritus fellow at the National Oceanography Centre in Southampton, described the argument as highly detailed and the arthropod hypothesis as very plausible. Stephen Hasiotis, a University of Kansas paleontologist, said arthropod makers had been proposed before, but the statistical rigor and number of samples made this study a particularly interesting contribution to trace-fossil research.
The maker remains unidentified, and even its classification as an arthropod is uncertain. Hasiotis suggested that multiple creatures could produce these networks. Paleodictyon’s roughly 500-million-year history therefore does not establish that one species or lineage survived all five of Earth’s mass extinctions. Hasiotis said the mesh-building behavior may have survived, been reinvented or evolved in different animal lineages.
Baucon hopes the study will encourage more deep-sea exploration. Hasiotis suggested cameras, underwater casts of modern burrows and DNA analysis of organic material left inside them as possible ways to investigate the maker’s identity. These are proposed avenues for research, not a confirmed identification.
Until we actually observe the producer in the deep sea, the enigma will remain.

A Utah deployment recorded thousands of nearby microearthquakes. Cable direction and measurement length matter when interpreting those signals.
3 min

Food & Water Watch compared rates at 500 major systems and found widespread affordability problems for low-income households.

Researchers found that existing cartilage cells changed their activity after treatment. Human surgical tissue also responded, but the approach has not been shown to work in patients.
4 min