
ExxonMobil and Suncor argue that damages awards would still regulate global conduct. Many similar lawsuits are paused while the Supreme Court considers whether federal law bars the claims.
Boulder’s climate lawsuit seeks money for local damage, not a court order restricting oil-company activity, its lawyer argued at the U.S. Supreme Court’s October 5, 2026 hearing. ExxonMobil and Suncor Energy countered that damages awards would effectively regulate their conduct worldwide. Colorado’s Supreme Court had allowed the case to move toward trial in state court; the companies now want it dismissed because, they argue, federal law bars the state claims. The hearing did not resolve that question.
The city and county of Boulder sued in 2018, alleging that the companies knowingly concealed and misrepresented the climate harms of burning fossil fuels. Boulder wants the companies to share costs borne locally, including the expense of protecting infrastructure, agricultural land and public health from hazards such as wildfires, drought and extreme rainfall. Those allegations remain unresolved; the hearing concerned whether the claims could proceed, not whether the companies were liable.
The court faces two distinct questions. The first is jurisdiction: whether it has the legal authority to review the case at this stage. The second is federal pre-emption: whether federal law overrides Boulder’s state-law claims. Cases generally reach the U.S. Supreme Court after lower courts have decided them, but Boulder’s lawsuit is still ongoing.

An experiment at 12 British Columbia sites found more stable soil carbon where logging left the organic surface layer intact.
Inside Climate News reports that the companies argue the federal Clean Air Act pre-empts state-law claims against oil companies tied to climate pollution. The Guardian notes that the same law says controlling air pollution at its source is primarily the responsibility of states and local governments. The dispute is therefore not simply whether federal pollution law exists, but whether it bars these state claims for damages.
The companies also argue that the Constitution gives the federal government exclusive control over pollution crossing state lines. Their brief invokes federal common law—rules developed by courts rather than enacted by Congress—from century-old decisions concerning environmental disputes across state lines. They contend that those rules remain effective through the Constitution’s structure despite the Clean Air Act’s later assignment of primary responsibility for local air pollution to states and local governments.
Kannon Shanmugam, the lawyer representing ExxonMobil and Suncor, argued that allowing such claims would let local juries shape national and international energy policy through large damages awards. The Trump administration supported the companies’ position: its lawyer, Sarah Harris, argued that states should not fill a gap in an inherently federal area with state law.
Boulder’s lawyer, Kevin Russell, argued that states can provide civil remedies for injuries within their borders even when the conduct causing them occurred elsewhere. When justices questioned applying state law to worldwide conduct, he offered a comparison: a car negligently manufactured in Canada can cause an injury in a U.S. state, where state law can hold the manufacturer liable.
Russell also argued that Boulder’s claim does not seek to limit pollution. In his view, neither the Clean Air Act nor the Constitution bars states from taking action merely because it could have a secondary effect of reducing pollution, whether through a gas tax or a claim for damages against oil companies.
Dennis Fan, who directs Columbia Law School’s Appellate Litigation Clinic and submitted a friend-of-the-court brief in the case, told the Guardian that the companies had difficulty identifying the federal law that would override the claims. His assessment was that the outcome remained too close to call.
The Guardian reported that a decision favoring Boulder, or a finding that the court lacks jurisdiction, would allow the lawsuit to continue in state court. A ruling accepting the companies’ pre-emption argument could reach dozens of other climate cases brought by state and local governments; its effect would depend on the ruling’s scope.
One potentially affected case is Middlesex County’s separate lawsuit in New Jersey state court, which Inside Climate News reported on October 2. The county alleges climate deception by major oil companies and the American Petroleum Institute and seeks compensation for climate-related damage. That complaint was not the proceeding heard on October 5. The institute called the county’s lawsuit baseless and argued that climate policy belongs in Congress rather than courts.
Justice Samuel Alito recused himself, leaving eight justices to decide the Boulder case. Eos reported that a tie would leave proceedings continuing in the lower courts. Both hearing reports expect a ruling by summer 2027.
3 min

Hospital responses describe prolonged painkiller shortages and higher spending to secure a blood-pressure drug. The figures cover responding trusts, not hospitals nationwide.
3 min

The light-control technique was used with gene delivery and special goggles in a vision trial. The result in one man does not establish a generally effective treatment.
3 min