Argus analyst warns of risks from US dyed-diesel relief

An Argus analyst warns that dye left in truck tanks and demand for supplies reserved for off-road users could complicate the temporary relief.

An Argus analyst warns that dye left in truck tanks and demand for supplies reserved for off-road users could complicate the temporary relief.
US President Donald Trump’s order of 5 October postpones, rather than cancels, federal tax payments on red-dyed diesel used on public roads through 31 December, without interest or penalties for qualifying users, Euronews reported on 6 October. BBC reported on 9 October that an Argus analyst warned of two practical risks: dye remaining in truck tanks after the relief ends, and highway users drawing down supplies reserved for rail operators and other users.
Red-dyed diesel is almost identical to ordinary diesel, but it is normally reserved for tractors and other off-road machinery and is exempt from highway taxes. The dye lets inspectors identify the fuel; using it on public roads normally carries penalties.
Euronews reported that Trump described the order as allowing anyone to purchase “tax-free red-dyed diesel for any reason,” but Treasury must determine who qualifies. The order does not single out truckers or farmers. Its practical relevance is mainly to diesel trucks and farm vehicles, since most US cars run on petrol.
Analysis
David Ruisard, pricing manager at commodities intelligence firm Argus, told BBC that red dye is extremely difficult to remove from fuel tanks. He warned that this could create compliance problems for trucking companies once the temporary relief ends, because having dyed diesel in a tank carries high fines when it is treated as tax evasion.
Ruisard also warned that businesses, including rail operators, set aside particular quantities of dyed diesel for their own use. If highway users begin consuming that fuel, they could deplete the supplies available to those businesses. His warning concerns a possible supply shortage, not an observed disruption.
BBC describes the measure as allowing normally tax-free off-road diesel to be used on US highways without federal levies. That conflicts with Euronews’s account of a payment deferral rather than an exemption. Fortune reported on 8 October that Treasury had not provided guidance on future tax liability; cancellation of the deferred bill remains unresolved.
Fortune reported on 8 October that the Society of Independent Gasoline Marketers of America and the National Association of Truck Stop Owners told their members they did not expect most reputable diesel retailers and fuel marketers to participate. Their joint statement said the tax was still owed, leaving limited upside. This was an expectation, not a count of retailers that had declined.
Finding the fuel could also be difficult for truckers. Patrick De Haan, GasBuddy’s head of petroleum analysis, told Fortune that dyed diesel is rarely a truck-stop fuel and is not widely available at many truck stops because it is typically sold for uses such as farming.
The White House told Fortune that more than 4,000 US retailers distribute dyed diesel. That figure does not establish that those retailers will offer it for highway use or participate in the tax deferral.
Fortune reported on 7 October that the federal diesel tax is 24.4 cents per gallon, citing the US Energy Information Administration. Larger relief would depend on states also suspending their diesel taxes. The order encourages that step but cannot require it.
| Basis | Amount | Qualification |
|---|---|---|
| Federal tax only: Fortune’s calculation | About $61 | Deferred, not cancelled, under the deferral account |
| Federal and state taxes: White House claim | More than $100 | Assumes states suspend their diesel taxes |
The federal tax represents about 4% of the Energy Information Administration’s national weekly diesel price for the week of 5 October, according to Fortune. AAA’s separate daily average for 5 October was more than 70% higher than a year earlier and close to the September record, Euronews reported.
| Measure | Date or period | Price per gallon | Data provider |
|---|---|---|---|
| US average | 5 October | $6.32 | AAA, cited by Euronews |
| Record | 22 September | $6.53 | AAA, cited by Euronews |
| US weekly average | Week of 5 October | About $6.20 | Energy Information Administration, cited by Fortune |
Analysis
Gilbert Metcalf, identified by Fortune in October 2026 as a visiting professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Sloan School of Management, said the order makes existing diesel available to more users rather than increasing production. He said US refineries were operating near record capacity, leaving little room to produce more diesel.
Metcalf warned that redirecting fuel to road users could raise prices for farmers and construction operators competing for the same supply. This was a possible price increase, not an observed effect of the order. Farmers already using tax-exempt red-dyed diesel in tractors and combines receive no new tax break, Fortune reported.
The order relies on a law allowing Treasury to postpone tax deadlines for people affected by disasters or military action. It gives Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent five days from 5 October to consult Secretary of War Pete Hegseth, determine whether those conditions are met and identify eligible taxpayers, Euronews reported.
Which taxpayers qualify and whether states will offer additional relief remain unclear. The White House also described possible action by federal authorities and state governors, including suspending inspections and dropping the tax; those possibilities are not confirmed additional relief.
Bessent is also tasked with finding ways, including legislation, to eliminate the deferred bill. Under the order described by Euronews, the tax will still be owed when the relief period ends on 31 December unless the administration secures cancellation.

Businesses can pay suppliers, employees and affiliates through the new service and subscribe under their existing SAP contracts.
1 min

October’s Reuters Tankan survey found manufacturers more optimistic and non-manufacturers less so, with both groups still positive overall.
2 min

The Cheyenne, Wyoming, project would combine utility grid power with third-party resources. Black Hills says Google must cover the full cost of electricity supply.
2 min