Nature retracts CCR5 paper after revised tests detect no frameshifting

The October 1 retraction notice says unintended RNA splicing likely produced the signal that the 2014 study interpreted as frameshifting.

The October 1 retraction notice says unintended RNA splicing likely produced the signal that the 2014 study interpreted as frameshifting.
Nature retracted a 2014 paper about CCR5 messenger RNA on October 1, 2026, saying its editors no longer trusted data supporting a key conclusion. According to the retraction notice, an unintended change to RNA in the original experiment likely produced a signal mistaken for ribosomal frameshifting. Revised tests detected no such frameshifting, undermining the study’s main conclusion.
Messenger RNA, or mRNA, carries instructions that ribosomes read to make proteins. Programmed −1 ribosomal frameshifting means the ribosome shifts its reading position backwards by one RNA unit, changing how it reads the instructions. The original study, published on July 9, 2014, tested a CCR5-derived sequence thought to trigger that shift.
The researchers inserted the sequence into p2luci1, a dual-luciferase reporter—a test system using two light-producing enzymes to measure activity. An SV40 promoter, a DNA region that drives RNA production, controlled the reporter. The system also contained an artificial intron, a segment normally removed during RNA processing, which enhanced RNA production.
Further investigation found a cryptic 3′ splice-acceptor site in the inserted CCR5 sequence, Nature says. This was a hidden site that RNA-processing machinery could use when removing a segment and joining the remaining RNA. It generated unintended RNA variants through splicing. That is a different process from a ribosome changing its reading position, but the notice suggests it accounted for the apparent frameshifting signal.
When the authors tried to reproduce their results, they used a revised dual-luciferase reporter. It replaced the SV40 promoter with a strong CMV promoter and omitted the artificial intron. In those tests, the CCR5-derived sequence did not produce detectable programmed −1 ribosomal frameshifting.
Nature says at least two other groups replicated these findings. The editors interpret the results as evidence that the earlier apparent frameshifting activity arose from a splicing artefact—an effect of the experimental setup rather than the process the test was intended to measure.

Computer models and a test with 100 volunteers suggest how visible wings could disrupt a predator’s aim, but effects on attacking birds remain uncertain.
3 min

Friends of the Dart’s platform links spill reports with treatment-capacity assessments and planned repairs. Its team acknowledges gaps and possible errors.
2 min

The study’s combined analysis reveals different links between particle-formation potential and cloud-forming particles across ice-covered, maritime and continental areas.
5 min