
Tradeoffs’ review of 166 nonprofit hospitals finds that only 10 guarantee full refunds, leaving some patients who qualify for free care unable to recover earlier payments.
A Tradeoffs investigation finds that many Texas nonprofit hospitals’ written policies put billing before financial-aid checks and restrict refunds once patients have paid. The findings show how patients can qualify for free care yet remain out of pocket after borrowing money to pay a hospital.
US hospitals can use existing information to identify patients eligible for financial assistance, also called charity care, and reduce or erase their bills without an application. This process is called “presumptive eligibility.” The investigation examined when hospitals use it and what happens to payments patients have already made.
Federal rules in force since 2016 require nonprofit hospitals to make reasonable efforts to identify patients eligible for assistance before suing them, selling their debt or harming their credit over unpaid bills, KFF Health News explained on 1 October. Automatic screening is one way to comply, but the rules do not require it before the first bill. This federal requirement does not apply to for-profit or public hospitals.
Tradeoffs examined the written financial-assistance policies of all 166 nonprofit general and children’s hospitals in Texas. Nearly every hospital’s policy allows automatic screening and bill reductions. The analysis describes written rules, not how often patients statewide actually receive screening, refunds or assistance.

The remaining policies say nothing about notifying patients whose balances have been cleared. Most hospitals also say they will not return payments made before screening. Federal rules require full refunds for some patients who submit applications, but those provisions do not apply to patients granted aid through presumptive eligibility, experts on the regulation told Tradeoffs.
Aimee Carlock said Texas Health Resources required her to pay $5,500 before scheduling surgery in August 2025 for severe uterine pain and bleeding. The self-employed house cleaner borrowed the money from her best friend and parents. Only after surgery did she learn that she qualified for free care, Tradeoffs reported.
Texas Health erased her remaining $16,000 bill but retained the $5,500 advance payment. Its policy offers refunds only for payments exceeding what the hospital typically charges someone with insurance. The system did not respond to an interview request after Carlock gave it permission to discuss her case.
Another patient, uninsured yoga instructor Becca Wahl, received a $38,000 emergency-room bill after treatment for a concussion at a Memorial Hermann hospital in Katy in October 2025. Wahl said the hospital later reduced the bill to $11,000 and offered a $1,000-a-month payment plan. She found Dollar For, a group that helps patients apply for assistance. One week after the group submitted her application, Memorial Hermann erased the bill.
According to the investigation, Wahl qualified under Memorial Hermann Health System’s policy and should not have received a bill: the policy requires screening before billing. After Wahl authorized discussion of her case, the system declined an interview. A spokesperson said it was dedicated to giving patients clear information about expected costs, coverage options and financial assistance.
Some hospitals described earlier screening than their policies require. AdventHealth said it screens some Texas patients before billing. Houston Methodist said it does so for uninsured patients. Neither system’s written policy requires that timing, Tradeoffs reported.
Anna Stelter, the Texas Hospital Association’s policy vice president, said hospitals first seek other payment sources, including Medicaid, a government health-coverage program, and county safety-net programs. She described charity care as a last resort. Stelter also said limited billing staff may prioritize helping people apply over notifying patients whose balances have already been forgiven.
Timing can matter for patients’ care. A 2022 study found that patients receiving hospital financial aid within weeks of treatment were more likely to return to a doctor and receive treatment for conditions such as diabetes and depression. A separate study published in 2024 found no effect on health, healthcare use or finances from erasing medical debts years later.
Financial assistance usually depends on the income of a patient’s whole household. In many states, hospitals set their own criteria. Some patients with insurance or middle incomes qualify, especially when their bills would consume a large share of their earnings. Patients who must apply can face demands for bank statements, pay stubs, tax returns and other documents; some do not know assistance exists.
For automatic screening, hospitals typically use public records, information patients previously provided or tools from consumer credit companies. Many pay for employment and credit checks. A home in a high-poverty ZIP code, or no listed address, can be enough for some hospitals to grant assistance. Common groups screened include people who are homeless and those already receiving government help with housing, food or prescriptions. In most states, hospitals choose who can skip an application, and some disclose little about their criteria.
Estimating income eligibility differs from estimating “propensity to pay”—how likely someone is to pay a bill, regardless of income. California and Oregon prohibit the latter because of concerns that hospitals might pursue reliable bill-payers even when their incomes qualify them for assistance.
By July 2027, six states will require automatic financial-aid screening for certain patients: California, Delaware, Illinois, Maryland, North Carolina and Oregon. Their eligibility rules differ. Maryland, for example, requires hospitals to erase bills proactively for patients who receive government help with food or utilities but are ineligible for Medicaid.
Illinois, North Carolina and Oregon already require screening of certain patients before hospitals send bills. California will require that timing starting in 2027. Elsewhere, hospitals may screen voluntarily before billing or first try to collect payment.
| Year | Share reporting the practice |
|---|---|
| 2016, the federal rules’ first year | 72% |
| 2022 | Around 90% |
These percentages count hospitals reporting a practice, not the share of eligible patients receiving help. A hospital can report screening while still requiring applications from other patients or checking eligibility only after bills go unpaid.
Oregon’s requirement began in July 2024, covering every uninsured patient, every patient on Medicaid and patients whose debt exceeded a set amount. Screening had to happen before billing. Lawmakers raised the debt threshold in 2026 amid concerns about imperfect screening tools and the effect on hospital finances.
| Rule | Amount owed |
|---|---|
| Requirement introduced in July 2024 | More than $500 |
| Threshold raised in 2026 | At least $1,500 for a single visit |
In 2025, roughly 80% of patients receiving financial help at the first 26 Oregon hospitals to publish data had not filled out an application. Those results show assistance reaching patients without applications at those hospitals; they do not measure all eligible patients statewide.
Tradeoffs also found that Oregon hospitals more than doubled their charity care, on average, during the law’s first full year. That analysis used available federal Medicare data from roughly two-thirds of the state’s hospitals.
Texas state representative Tom Oliverson proposed legislation in 2025 requiring nonprofit hospitals to screen patients and provide aid before sending bills, with penalties for hospitals that failed to comply. The bill failed, but he told Tradeoffs that he plans to reintroduce it in 2027.
Oliverson said hospitals already caring for a higher share of low-income patients would be exempt from his proposed requirements. For other nonprofit hospitals, the proposal would move financial-aid decisions ahead of billing rather than leaving patients to seek relief after payment demands arrive.
Ultrafast laser measurements and theoretical models revealed how a short-lived electron–hole pair contracted in an organic semiconductor—not through direct photography.
3 min

Repeated measurements during long space-station missions found a return toward preflight heart measures among exercising astronauts. The findings do not prove exercise caused recovery or guarantee readiness for Mars.
3 min

A separate 7% of people renewing coverage under the rules lost their insurance. Most denials and losses followed unanswered verification requests.
3 min