Bill Withers’ publisher seeks injunction and damages over Olivia Dean’s ‘I’ve Seen It’


Mattie Music seeks a permanent court order against further infringement and seizure or destruction of infringing copies. MBW’s account also identifies UMG as a defendant.
Mattie Music Group, doing business as Bleunig Music, wants a permanent court order barring the companies behind Olivia Dean’s “I’ve Seen It” from further infringing its copyright in “Just the Two of Us,” co-written by Bill Withers. It also seeks an order allowing the seizure, impounding—holding copies in custody—or destruction of infringing copies. The publisher alleges that Dean’s track copies the older song’s melody, according to Music Business Worldwide (MBW), which obtained the complaint.
Mattie Music seeks its losses plus the defendants’ profits from the alleged infringement, with the amounts to be proved at trial. Alternatively, it can choose statutory damages—amounts set by law—before final judgment, up to $150,000 per work if infringement is found to be willful. These are the publisher’s requests, not court orders, and its infringement allegations are not court findings.
The complaint names Capitol Records, LLC; Universal Music Group, Inc.; Sony Publishing (US) LLC, doing business as Sony/ATV Songs LLC; and Kobalt Music Publishing America, Inc., doing business as Songs of Kobalt Music Publishing. It alleges that Capitol and UMG distributed and exploited recordings of the accused song, while Sony and Kobalt licensed and exploited its publishing rights—the rights in the composition rather than the recording.
MBW notes that UMG’s US recorded-music company is ordinarily named in litigation as UMG Recordings, Inc., and Sony’s US publishing company as Sony Music Publishing (US) LLC. Those are not the names used in this complaint. Neither Dean nor her co-writers Bastian Langebaek and Max Wolfgang is named as a defendant.

“I’ve Seen It” appears on the British singer-songwriter’s second studio album, The Art of Loving, which reached No. 3 on the Billboard 200 in January. Billboard reports that Withers released “Just the Two of Us” with Grover Washington Jr. in 1980; it later won the Grammy Award for Best R&B Song.
Mattie Music says it hired musicologist Alexander Stewart, a specialist who studies music, to compare the songs. According to the publisher, Stewart concluded that they “contain substantial similarities in protectable musical expression, including repeated copying of the distinctively protectable melody.” The claim concerns musical material the publisher says is eligible for copyright protection, particularly the melody.
Mattie Music’s lawyers argue that the number, character and arrangement of the shared musical features support an inference of copying rather than coincidence, independent creation or reliance on common musical elements. These are the plaintiff’s allegations and its account of the expert’s conclusions, not a court finding.
Representatives for Universal Music Group, Sony and Dean had not immediately responded to Billboard’s requests for comment when its October 1 report was published. A Kobalt representative declined to comment.
Music Business Worldwide contacted Capitol parent UMG, Sony and Kobalt for comment. None had responded when its October 2 report was published.
Three-part stages and more than 50 planned chips are meant to help newcomers without dropping the challenge for longtime players. Override adds a separate trade-off: power now, lost abilities afterward.
2 min

Jake Witzenfeld followed a Jewish Israeli and Palestinian-Israeli gay couple as they became parents. He explains how the October 7 attack changed his access and the documentary’s approach to their differences.
3 min

IGN’s hands-on preview describes a four-versus-four game where troops gather resources, open defenses to attack and help players change the familiar three-lane battlefield.
3 min